Stipe's Top 5 wins vs Fedor's Top 5 Wins, Which is More Impressive?

[Steve-French]

Fedor

1. Big Nog (Dec)
2. Cro Cop (Dec)
3. Andrei Arlovski (KO)
4. Tim Sylvia (Sub)
5. Mark Coleman (Sub)

Honorable Mention Mark Hunt (Sub)

Stipe

1. Werdum (KO)
2. JDS (KO)
3. Francis Ngannou (DEC)
4. Overeem (KO)
5. Andrei Arlovski(KO)

Honorable Mention Mark Hunt (KO)

 

[Taric]

__ Fedor____________________Stipe

1. Nogueira 1________________Werdum
2. Nogueira 3________________Overeem
3. Cro Cop__________________JDS
4. Arlovski___________________Arlovski
5. Sylvia____________________Ngannou
6. Herring___________________Hunt
7. Coleman 1________________Nelson
8. Hunt_____________________Gonzaga
9. Randleman________________Shane del Rosario
10. Babalu___________________Fabio Maldonado

Everybody on Fedor's list has either been a UFC/PRIDE champion, or fought in a UFC/PRIDE championship fight.
Stipe's list has Fabio Maldonado and Shane del Rosario as part of his best 10 wins.

Happy to help out.

 

[Perrichet]

Stipe by far

 

[jenspulverizer]

stipe hands down not even close. Compare Werdum to Stipe that's a better comparison.

 

[Taric]

Flaw with the OP is that Nogueira should be listed twice and Coleman taken off.

 

[KevinLee]

Fedor

1. Big Nog (Dec)
2. Cro Cop (Dec)
3. Andrei Arlovski (KO)
4. Tim Sylvia (KO)
5. Mark Coleman (Sub)

Honorable Mention Mark Hunt (Sub)

Stipe

1. Werdum (KO)
2. JDS (KO)
3. Francis Ngannou (DEC)
4. Overeem (KO)
5. Andrei Arlovski(KO)

Honorable Mention Mark Hunt (KO)

Fedor is the most overrated fighter in MMA history.

 

[CubicleGangster]

__ Fedor____________________Stipe

1. Nogueira 1________________Werdum
2. Nogueira 3________________Overeem
3. Cro Cop__________________JDS
4. Arlovski___________________Arlovski
5. Sylvia____________________Ngannou
6. Herring___________________Hunt
7. Coleman 1________________Nelson
8. Hunt_____________________Gonzaga
9. Randleman________________Shane del Rosario
10. Babalu___________________Fabio Maldonado

Everybody on Fedor's list has either been a UFC/PRIDE champion, or fought in a UFC/PRIDE championship fight.
Stipe's list has Fabio Maldonado and Shane del Rosario as part of his best 10 wins.

Happy to help out.

Not sure why you're harping on SDR as a win for Stipe. Dude was a top prospect with a high ceiling that never came to fruition due to a nasty car crash and death. Puts a bad taste in my mouth to see someone use him as a way to discredit a fighter.

 

[funksoulbrother]

__ Fedor____________________Stipe

1. Nogueira 1________________Werdum
2. Nogueira 3________________Overeem
3. Cro Cop__________________JDS
4. Arlovski___________________Arlovski
5. Sylvia____________________Ngannou
6. Herring___________________Hunt
7. Coleman 1________________Nelson
8. Hunt_____________________Gonzaga
9. Randleman________________Shane del Rosario
10. Babalu___________________Fabio Maldonado

Everybody on Fedor's list has either been a UFC/PRIDE champion, or fought in a UFC/PRIDE championship fight.
Stipe's list has Fabio Maldonado and Shane del Rosario as part of his best 10 wins.

Happy to help out.

Stipe beat hunt also

 

[Taric]

Not sure why you're harping on SDR as a win for Stipe. Dude was a top prospect with a high ceiling that never came to fruition due to a nasty car crash and death. Puts a bad taste in my mouth to see someone use him as a way to discredit a fighter.

He isn't, nor ever was, considered an elite or championship caliber fighter. That's literally all I said, and it's factual.
If you take issue with that I'm not sure what to tell you, because he wasn't champion caliber class.

Stipe beat hunt also

That's why he's on the list.

 

[jonathan274]

__ Fedor____________________Stipe

1. Nogueira 1________________Werdum
2. Nogueira 3________________Overeem
3. Cro Cop__________________JDS
4. Arlovski___________________Arlovski
5. Sylvia____________________Ngannou
6. Herring___________________Hunt
7. Coleman 1________________Nelson
8. Hunt_____________________Gonzaga
9. Randleman________________Shane del Rosario
10. Babalu___________________Fabio Maldonado

Everybody on Fedor's list has either been a UFC/PRIDE champion, or fought in a UFC/PRIDE championship fight.
Stipe's list has Fabio Maldonado and Shane del Rosario as part of his best 10 wins.

Happy to help out.

Thanks. You saved me some time. To add, half of Stipes list were far past their prime.

 

[sutherland]

__ Fedor____________________Stipe

1. Nogueira 1________________Werdum
2. Nogueira 3________________Overeem
3. Cro Cop__________________JDS
4. Arlovski___________________Arlovski
5. Sylvia____________________Ngannou
6. Herring___________________Hunt
7. Coleman 1________________Nelson
8. Hunt_____________________Gonzaga
9. Randleman________________Shane del Rosario
10. Babalu___________________Fabio Maldonado

Everybody on Fedor's list has either been a UFC/PRIDE champion, or fought in a UFC/PRIDE championship fight.
Stipe's list has Fabio Maldonado and Shane del Rosario as part of his best 10 wins.

Happy to help out.

Yet two guy on that list beat fedor werdum and lmfao fabio Maldonado

 

[vertical_leap]

I like the fight where Stipe is dominated and knocked out by Stefan Struve. lol

 

[ThePatriot]

To be fair, Overeem and Arlovski have no chins + Werdum literally ran into stipe's fist

Tough to say, the guys on Stipe list to me are better fighters but the guys on Fedors list were all champs

 

[VVarhead]

I like the fight where Stipe is dominated and knocked out by Stefan Struve. lol

There's a thing that good fighters do, it's called: evolve

 

[Bluntforce420]

__ Fedor____________________Stipe

1. Nogueira 1________________Werdum
2. Nogueira 3________________Overeem
3. Cro Cop__________________JDS
4. Arlovski___________________Arlovski
5. Sylvia____________________Ngannou
6. Herring___________________Hunt
7. Coleman 1________________Nelson
8. Hunt_____________________Gonzaga
9. Randleman________________Shane del Rosario
10. Babalu___________________Fabio Maldonado

Everybody on Fedor's list has either been a UFC/PRIDE champion, or fought in a UFC/PRIDE championship fight.
Stipe's list has Fabio Maldonado and Shane del Rosario as part of his best 10 wins.

Happy to help out.

You didnt help out. TS is comparing their 5 best wins and you came along and compared their 10 best wins to make Fedor look better

 

[Vehap1]

Feder refused to fight Overeem, ofc that was back in the days when he was Ubereem
Stipe beat the crap out of reem

 

[CubicleGangster]

He isn't, nor ever was, considered an elite or championship caliber fighter. That's literally all I said, and it's factual.

No need to piss on his dead ashes just so you can say your boy Fedor is better

 

[Money509]

Only a Fedor fanboy would vote for him. Guys resume is shit.

 

[Taric]

You didnt help out. TS is comparing their 5 best wins and you came along and compared their 10 best wins to make Fedor look better

TS didn't correctly put Fedor's top 5 wins. His best two wins are both against Nogueira.
Which means all of Fedor's top 5 list are against top 10 heavyweight all time greats while Stipe's list includes Ngannou.

 

[GoldenAzazel]

__ Fedor____________________Stipe

1. Nogueira 1________________Werdum
2. Nogueira 3________________Overeem
3. Cro Cop__________________JDS
4. Arlovski___________________Arlovski
5. Sylvia____________________Ngannou
6. Herring___________________Hunt
7. Coleman 1________________Nelson
8. Hunt_____________________Gonzaga
9. Randleman________________Shane del Rosario
10. Babalu___________________Fabio Maldonado

Everybody on Fedor's list has either been a UFC/PRIDE champion, or fought in a UFC/PRIDE championship fight.
Stipe's list has Fabio Maldonado and Shane del Rosario as part of his best 10 wins.

Happy to help out.

To be fair though Maldonado beat the shit out of Fedor.