So can Soccer Players make for good MMA fighters?

What a load of BS, bud.

Rules are clear, no matter how much you want to want to draw it into a grey area.
Rules are ambiguous and change, referee's interpret things differently, footballing cultures interpret things differently, referee's act differently depending on Tournaments and Leagues, time and experience, rules are introduced and taken away. Almost like laws around the world.

FLOL at this elitist BS. They are too poor to understand right from wrong!! You have to have schooling and money to understand what lying is, such poor sobs they are!
Right & Wrong is also subjective.. Everyone/everywhere holds different values and nobody is perfect. My point being here that when one comes from poverty, possibly from a broken home, possibly without a family structure or role model figure, you're probably gonna have some tough times somewhere down the road with your world view and holding strong to morals of what societies consensus might typically say is right and wrong, I know I did. Especially when you potentially are being manipulated by a coach with an agenda from a very young age fuelling you with $ and a Win Above All Else mentality.

Not to mention they constantly do it in first world countries too, so what the fuck are you talking about?
Doesn't matter where they do it, matters where they learned to do it. One can be from nothing and also be raised in a wealthy country.. Most footballers around the world are from poor backgrounds.
This is coached into them, Managers don't play by the rules all the time and Players listen to their managers, they start listening to managers at a very young age, Managers get sacked if they don't win, players get sacked if they don't abide, players get fined or suspended if they are found cheating.

They aren't mutually exclusive, but in the case of your example they are pretty opposed to each other.
Maybe, If a harmless lie can net me a million dollars and I chose not to I would be both honourable and dumb imo.
I'm not suggesting that all cheating is harmless though.

And this is relevant to diving how? I never said that there wasn't any integrity in soccer, I'm saying there isn't any with diving.

You didn't specify what particular notion of cheating you meant. I was simply saying that some take the honourable and integral approach, not to pushback on anything you said, more just for conversational purposes.
 
Last edited:
I'd love to see Ibra give it a go.
9670bf480a848ebb35a86f2fa142bfde.jpg

72dc63833e6bbc7bf52c98677487e0e8.jpg


One of my favourite goals of all time.
anigif_enhanced-2017-1428918250-8.gif


Not much of a fan but even the camera man got injured trying to follow the action. Amazing.
 
Not much of a fan but even the camera man got injured trying to follow the action. Amazing.
<Lmaoo>Hadn't occurred to me and i've watched that goal plenty plenty times, indeed he is well and truly bamboozled.
 
Historically, I actually think they do make good fighters. I'm not a soccer player, but there are a lot of high level fighters that used to play soccer -- Aldo, JDS, Florian, Mousasi, and others. Some of the best wrestlers I've competed with actually had backgrounds playing soccer as well; you wouldn't think they do, but I feel evidence suggests that they do make good fighters.
Correlation does not equal causation
 
Rules are ambiguous and change, referee's interpret things differently, footballing cultures interpret things differently, referee's act differently depending on Tournaments and Leagues, time and experience, rules are introduced and taken away. Almost like laws around the world.

Please stay on the specific topic at hand and and not try to make this overly broad.
Show me where the rules about diving and deceiving the ref are different and/or when they made changes to them..


Right & Wrong is also subjective.. Everyone holds different values and nobody is perfect. My point being here that when one comes from poverty, possibly from a broken home, possibly without a family structure or role model figure, you're probably gonna have some tough times somewhere down the road with your world view and holding strong to morals of what societies consensus might typically say is right and wrong, I know I did. Especially when you potentially are being manipulated by a coach with an agenda.

Never said iit would be easy, bud.

But please spare me the sympathy talk for millonaires playing a game to become filthy rich as if they have to cheat to survive . They might have had hard times growing up, but that doesn't buy you a free pass to cheat for the rest of your life.

Every person is responsible for their own choices, doesn't matter the background or who tried to convince you

Doesn't matter where they do it, matters where they learned to do it. One can be from nothing and also be raised in a wealthy country.. Most footballers around the world are from poor backgrounds.
This is coached into them, Managers don't play by the rules all the time and Players listen to their managers, they start listening to managers at a very young age, Managers get sacked if they don't win.

It doesn't matter where they learned it or from whom they learned it, it matters that they chose to do what people know instinctually is wrong.

For example if you had an abusive dad, that doesn't mean you have no choice but to become one yourself too, though that does happen a lot. If you abuse your kids you are still responsible for that, even though you learned it from your father. Or if you learned lying from your family, you are still responsible for every lie you speak


Maybe, If a harmless lie can net me a million dollars and I chose not to I would be both honourable and dumb imo.
I'm not suggesting that all cheating is harmless though.

Harmless? Are you not stealing whatever opportunity you gain from the deceit from the person or the team that would have gotten it otherwise? If it would do so much for you, it would have potentially done just as much for another and you robbed him/them of that.

You didn't specify what particular notion of cheating you meant. I was simply saying that some take the honourable and integral approach, not to pushback on anything you said, more just for conversational purposes.

I thought it was pretty clear that the subject was diving, though I did not follow your whole conversation, so maybe there was some ambiguity from something I didn't read.
 
Last edited:
Never mind Zlatan boys imagine Edgar Davids as an MMA fighter, strong, powerful, explosive, ridiculous cardio. Dude could have been dangerous.

It's these strong box to box cardio machines I think would have made the best fighters.
 
Please stay at the specific topic at and and not try to make this overly broad.
Show me where the rules about diving and deceiving the ref are differen and when they made changes to them..




Never said iit would be easy, bud.

But please spare me the sympathy talk for millonaires playing a game to become filthy rich as if they have to cheat to survive . They might have hard times growing up, but that doesn't buy you a free pass to cheat for the rest of your life.

Every person is responsible for their own choices, doesn't matter the background or who tried to convince you



It doesn't matter where they learned it or from who they learned it, it matters that they chose to do what people know instinctually is wrong.

For example if you had an abusive dad, that doesn't mean you have no choice but to become one yourself too, though that does happen a lot. If you abuse your kids you are still responsible for that, even though you learned it from your father. Or if you learned lying from your family, you are still responsible for every lie you speak




Harmless? Are you not stealing whatever opportunity you gain from the deceit from the person or the team that would have gotten it otherwise? If it would do so much for you, it would have potentially done just as much for another and you robbed him/them of that.



I thought it was pretty clear that the subject was diving, though I did not follow your whole conversation, so maybe there was some ambiguity from something I didn't read.

If anything the laws on diving and play acting have got tighter because you didn't really need them pre 90s as nobody did it.

It's without a doubt the most embarrassing part of the game.
 
If anything the laws on diving and play acting have got tighter because you didn't really need them pre 90s as nobody did it.

It's without a doubt the most embarrassing part of the game.

Yeah, I'm not a huge soccer fan, but I know a little from it being the national sports here and having watched a good amount with friends and family, and what you say sounds believable to me.
 
Please stay at the specific topic at and and not try to make this overly broad.
Show me where the rules about diving and deceiving the ref are differen and when they made changes to them..
I can't show you specifically a written change in the rules around diving, that is something you can only see from watching football around the world and noticing the cultural differences in how games are subjectively refereed. Like in MMA one ref lets a foul go, another will penalise the same foul. In The Champions League referee's are stricter on diving than is say La Ligue or top flight of Brazil, even the use of VAR is inconsistent across the world.

Never said uit would be easy, bud.

But please spare me the sympathy talk for millonaires playing a game to become filthy rich as if they have to cheat to survive . They might have hard times growing up, but that doesn't buy you a free pass to cheat for the rest of your life.
You are talking about a small percentage of footballers in the top leagues of(mostly) Europe who are millionaires, I am talking broadly, I know footballers, and have family members who have been professional footballers who are not nor have ever been close to being millionaires.

I never said it does buy you a free pass, I am just explaining why it happens, not morally justifying it as something everyone should do. I hate diving, I just get why they do it, but if it means my team wins the league or a trophy, fuck it let's celebrate.

Every person is responsible for their own chouces, doesn't matter the background or who tried to convince you


It doesn't matter where they learned it or from who they learned it, it matters that they chose to do what people know instinctually know is wrong.
I didn't deny that either, just giving context as to why some might not know any better. Many things could be considered wrong but are accepted, i've played innocent card games where people have cheated, it hasn't ruined my relationships or my day lol.

For example if you had an abusive dad, that doesn't mean you have no choice but to become one yourself too, though that does happen a lot. If you abuse your kids you are still responsible for that, even though you learned it from your father. Or if you learned lying from your family, you are still responsible for every lie you speak
Absolutely, but many people don't learn that, or imo care if they do.. People fuck up and are oblivious to the harm they are causing, some people are ass holes and are completely aware.. Just like with MMA I don't look to these athletes as role models for behavioural wisdom. If I wanted to aim for a utopian situation I would boycott watching company owned sports altogether.

Harmless? Are you not stealing whatever opportunity you gain from the deceit from the person or the team that would have gotten it otherwise? If it would do so much for you, it would have potentially done just as much for another and you robbed him/them of that.

Indeed, but anyone has the ability to try and con the ref if they please, not all dives result in major consequences, there are few if any top teams completely innocent. But yes if your dive meant the other team loses then for sure you've dicked them over, but this is a world where everyone is doing this to each other, it is the norm.
When DC poked Stipe in the eye he got massive shit for it, when Stipe poked DC in the eye many saw it as revenge, as time goes on most will forget the details and just remember the results and the champions.

I thought it was pretty clear that the subject was diving, though I did not follow your whole conversation, so maybe there was some ambiguity from something I didn't read
Well it was but when you initially used the word "Cheat" I took that incorrectly as more broadly, there's many more layers to the world of cheating and Football/Soccer than just diving but we can save that for another day lol.
 
Last edited:
If anything the laws on diving and play acting have got tighter because you didn't really need them pre 90s as nobody did it.

It's without a doubt the most embarrassing part of the game.
Is it though? More embarrassing than the thousands of kids/young adults who get left in dirt who don't make the grade? More embarrassing than the financial corruption? More embarrassing than fans still supporting players after committing heinous crimes? More embarrassing than hooliganism and the racism that comes with that? More embarrassing than Ballotelli setting his house on fire with Fireworks lol?
I just can't see these things happening in Kabaddi.
 
I can't show you specifically a written change in the rules around diving, that is something you can only see from watching football around the world and noticing the cultural differences in how games are subjectively refereed. Like in MMA one ref lets a foul go, another will penalise the same foul. In The Champions League referee's are stricter on diving than is say La Ligue or top flight of Brazil, even the use of VAR is inconsistent across the world.


You are talking about a small percentage of footballers in the top leagues of(mostly) Europe who are millionaires, I am talking broadly, I know footballers, and have family members who have been professional footballers who are not nor have ever been close to being millionaires.

I never said it does buy you a free pass, I am just explaining why it happens, not morally justifying it as something everyone should do. I hate diving, I just get why they do it, but if it means my team wins the league or a trophy, fuck it let's celebrate.


I didn't deny that either, just giving context as to why some might not know any better. Many things could be considered wrong but are accepted, i've played innocent card games where people have cheated, it hasn't ruined my relationships or my day lol.


Absolutely, but many people don't learn that, or imo care if they do.. People fuck up and are oblivious to the harm they are causing, some people are ass holes and are completely aware.. Just like with MMA I don't look to these athletes as role models for behavioural wisdom. If I wanted to aim for a utopian situation I would boycott watching company owned sports altogether.



Indeed, but anyone has the ability to try and con the ref if they please, not all dives result in major consequences, there are few if any top teams completely innocent. But yes if your dive meant the other team loses then for sure you've dicked them over, but this is a world where everyone is doing this to each other, it is the norm.
When DC poked Stipe in the eye he got massive shit for it, when Stipe poked DC in the eye many saw it as revenge, as time goes on most will forget the details and just remember the results and the champions.


Well it was but when you initially used the word "Cheat" I took that incorrectly as more broadly, there's many more layers to the world of cheating and Football/Soccer than just diving but we can save that for another day lol.


Why though? I understand why people lie and it goes deeper than just growing up poor, poor people can be honest and a lot of rich people lie.

My issue was that you described sticking to being a honest person as being a dumbfuck. Bunch of sad sob stories doesn't change that valuing honesty over money is not dumb.

Yeah, you seem to have a tendency to see things too broadly maybe. Just an observation, not trying to give you shit.

And about the rules and their implementation, Jon Jones got away with a bunch of eye pokes because the refs let him, doesn't make it any less wrong or any less cheating.
 
Is it though? More embarrassing than the thousands of kids/young adults who get left in dirt who don't make the grade? More embarrassing than the financial corruption? More embarrassing than fans still supporting players after committing heinous crimes? More embarrassing than hooliganism and the racism that comes with that? More embarrassing than Ballotelli setting his house on fire with Fireworks lol?
I just can't see these things happening in Kabaddi.

I mean in terms of what happens on the pitch.
 
Why though? I understand why people lie and it goes deeper than just growing up poor, poor people can be honest and a lot of rich people lie.

My issue was thay you described sticking to being a honest person as being a dumbfuck. Bunch of sad sob stories doesn't change that valuing honesty over money is not a dumb.

Yeah, you seem to have a tendency to see things too broadly maybe. Just an observation, not trying to give you shit.

An d about the rules and their implementation, Jon Jones got away eith a bunch of eye pokes because the refs let him, doesn't make it any less wrong or any less cheating.
For sure, but i'd take a good guess that most kids from functional backgrounds aren't put in as many positions where lying may be considered the safest way to deal with a situation.

Circumstantially i'd say it could be. But we'll have to agree to disagree on that point I guess.

No problem, appreciate the criticism. Football is something i've been passionate about since around 1995, I appreciate conversations like this.

mmm I guess bringing up MMA was a bad analogy cos my main issue with an Eye Poke is the physical damage it can do rather than the rule breaking itself, it is a far worse cheat than say putting your toes in the cage or diving imo .
 
For sure, but i'd take a good guess that most kids from functional backgrounds aren't put in as many positions where lying may be considered the safest way to deal with a situation.

Middle class or upper class families can be just as disfunctional. For example, rich kids often have a lot of opportunity and ease to get hooked on drugs, because they have the money for it and the money will attractvthe drugs.

Circumstantially i'd say it could be. But we'll have to agree to disagree on that point I guess.

But you understand that your line of reasoning is the same as a lot of people use to justify corrupt behavior? It is very, very rarely the case that there is absolutely no way to improve your situation in an honest way. But it often is harder to do, and people often will choose the easy way and cheat, not out of necessity but out of greed or laziness, but they will try to tell/deceive themselves that they HAD to.

No problem, appreciate the criticism. Football is something i've been passionate about since around 1995, I appreciate conversations like this.

No problem, bud. Always appreciate your posts and the conversations i have with you.

mmm I guess bringing up MMA was a bad analogy cos my main issue with an Eye Poke is the physical damage it can do rather than the rule breaking itself, it is a far worse cheat than say putting your toes in the cage or diving .

Sure, it's more severe. But it's still cheating to gain an advantage.
I'm also not saying that these people are completely reprehensible because they dive. But the act itself is still wrong, not a mortal sin or anything like that, but if these same footballers talk about wanting to be good examples for kids/fans, maybe they should stop perpetuating a culture of dishonesty.
 
Last edited:
The fact they're soccer players isnt really relevant, its just that they're from a sport that has a massive talent pool. So on that basis, yes, just playing the numbers game there is going to be plenty of soccer players who would have been good/great fighters if they'd gone down a different career path.
 
@Jose Beehive not all of them might be millonaires, but they probably still have a decent enough salary that they aren't struggling anymore, and they do have a very ideal job most would say (playing a game/their hobby/their passion to make money). So they still have it pretty good.
 
Nah bro true A level athletes only have one round of cardio and need to use an inhaler between rounds.

Good old Murrrican sportsball players are the only A level athletes and the only guys who can translate over to MMA and win belts with 3 months of padwork bro.

Whether it be the guys who put on padding to carry an egg past a line, or the guys who jump and put a ball in a hoop. No other athletes can compare bro.

I'm not Murican and I think American football is utter shite, I also roll my eyes at all the "our best fighters are in the NFL and NBA" American cope, BUT those NFL players are vastly more athletic than "soccer" (just calling it that to avoid confusion) players on average tbh. It puts a massive premium on raw physical attributes, more than any other team sport, the combine is an example of this. You can get locked out of positions or the sport altogether for not matching the (really fucking high) size, strength, speed etc prerequisites. With soccer you just need to be moderately athletic and disciplined when it comes to maintaining your fitness level. The rest of the game is about what you do with the ball.

If you wanna use a non-Murica sport, rugby players are better athletes than soccer players on average too. Because again their sport requires the athletes to be more physically exceptional to meet the norms. Although again, its also less skilled than soccer.
 
Back
Top