Good posts. I mostly agree, though Scream 3's cheesiness keeps me from considering it great. It was just way too silly. But.... the killer in Scream 3 is my favorite of the entire franchise. I love how the big reveal was impossible to predict (whereas all the others had a ton of foreshadowing).
The first film is hands down the best, and my favorite.
S2 is ok, though I consider it quite boring overall. Killers were cool.
Scream 4 though, what a horrific piece of absolute diarrhea. They went
full retard with that one. I can't say enough negative things about it. It was out and out an awful piece of shit from beginning to end (with only like 2 interesting parts hidden deeply within). ("Fuck you Bruce Willis" was pretty funny though). Literally, for S4, it's as if Craven forgot how to make movies and made a legit Stab film (a retarded
spoof of Scream, aka Scary Movie) it was
that bad. They tried to be way too "funny" and never took anything seriously. Also, the color composition of the whole film was WAY too over-saturated. It looked NOTHING like the original three films (which all looked exactly alike). Ugh, it just makes me want to vomit thinking about it. I hate S4. I abhor it. It is an abomination on this Earth, and its very existance is a cancer. I wish it was never made. It's a slap in the face to the fans and the rest of the franchise. It's such a stupid and lame film. If I could, I would slap Wes Craven, Bob Weinstein, and Kevin Williamson in the face for bringing that utter farce to the screen. Fuck Scream 4.
That being said, I always wanted a 4th Scream film. Just not the one they gave us. I wanted something as serious as the first film, but with the size and scope of the third film, with a great killer to boot. We got none of that. Killers sucked. Motive sucked. Reveal sucked. Entire execution sucked.
As great as Scream is, Scream 4 is the exact polar opposite. It's abject! It's like comparing Tommy Wiseau to Steven Spielberg.