Rhea Ripley or Jade Cargill?

[Nameless Ghoul]

Now that rumors are heavy about her going to RAW, it's a legitimate question because they wouldn't place Jade there without title plans. Who is "best for business"? Sure Jade has always looked "like a million bucks", but that's the only thing that I keep hearing about her. Nothing about her work in ring or promos. Add in the concession that she is still "green" on top of that? At the moment she is potentially just a more muscular Nia Jax. I'll take Rhea, who is five years younger, and already the total package.

 

[The Clinch]

 

[clutchCAT420]

Rhea ia disgusting with those nasty tats, makeup and lesbo haircut. Jade is perfection who doesnt need the added shit to stand out. Thats the difference

 

[Kung Fu Kowboy]

Jade getting the Goldberg WCW Streak is best for business

 

[Batjester]

Jade getting the Goldberg WCW Streak is best for business

Only to have Flair break that streak, just like with Asuka.

 

[Sycho Sid]

Only to have Flair break that streak, just like with Asuka.

Only after disappearing randomly for a few months, coming back looking like a completely different person, and then pinning her with no build, while somehow trying to be a face.

 

[Batjester]

Only after disappearing randomly for a few months, coming back looking like a completely different person, and then pinning her with no build, while somehow trying to be a face.

The fact this isn't even parody is sad.

 

[RichardPriors]

Both are money. Rhea is a superstar but I feel her tatted look is going to be somewhat problematic for future face turns. People like to have their damsels in distress for those and her appearance isn't geared towards that. But this girl is so talented it probably doesn't even matter, she'll pull it off. Jade is Glamazon 2.0

 

[TKing]

Jade has one of the best plug in and play looks of anyone in wrestling and she can work on that alone for a while. That being said Rhea has a different look, good in the ring, very smooth in her movements and can sell.

Jade is stiff, she moves around the ring with little fluid motion at times and in AEW her selling was rough. I think she will improve but not as quick as people think.

 

[Crawler89]

Jade has more cross over appeal, like Bianca Belair.

But Im taking Mami every day. good wrestler, over like rover, want her to step on me...

 

[Big Nasty Edison]

Rhea is a goddess.

 

[Wrath of Foamy]

Rhea.

Rhea is established. She's set. No problems.

Jade had the TBS title, but she was kept from the Women's Title picture. I don't see her having much success against the Flairs and the Belairs.

 

[Clark Rogers]

Jade is a specimen, but Rhea is special too.

Rhea has the full package already, Jade has most of it but needs work in the ring, just usual green stuff but needs polished.

I take Rhea today, reexamine every 6-12 months lol

 

[liner]

Rhea ia disgusting with those nasty tats, makeup and lesbo haircut. Jade is perfection who doesnt need the added shit to stand out. Thats the difference

I normally don't like girls with lots of tats. But there is something about Rhea that really does it for me. She's hot as fuck. Jade too. But Rhea has that something and I don't know what it is but I like it

 

[Small Town Andrew]

I am not a big fan of either. When I see Jade I think Chyna. Looks like a man.

Rhea has a good look and personality though so i will go with her

 

[borntoloseNOT]

I would try and get with both

 

[liner]

The other thing Rhea has going for her. Her and Dom are fucking money. She must keep working with Dom. him getting boo'd out of every building is the best thing on TV right now