- Joined
- Sep 25, 2015
- Messages
- 22,699
- Reaction score
- 31,819
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005)
After taking the family to see a matinee of Wonka last week I thought I’d show my kids the 1971 Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory which in my opinion is a classic with an iconic portrayal of Willy Wonka by Gene Wilder. My kids liked it, and the funny thing is my kids can’t pick up on sarcasm so my 8 year old son commented when we were done that Wilder’s Wonka was “such a nice man” lol.
In any event, I had never watched Tim Burton’s Charlie and the Chocolate Factory featuring Johnny Depp as Willy Wonka, so we watched it the other night. I hated everything about this movie. Depp and Burton have a long history of making movies together, most of which are good, but just nothing worked in this movie for me. I hated Depp’s portrayal of Wonka. Dude was a mentally ill creep with literal daddy issues and a patently obvious disdain for children. The new musical numbers for the Oompa Loompas were atrocious. Even the portrayals of the children weren’t as memorable. OG Veruca Salt was a world class cunt. The new one was just whiny. And the new Mike TV was a vicious little bastard.
Even the story wasn’t as good. I’ve heard the inclusion of Slugworth as red herring villain was something they added for the 1971 movie and wasn’t in the novel, but to me that was somewhat critical to the plot as it gave Charlie the opportunity to do something good to prove his trustworthiness and values by returning the everlasting gobstopper to Wonka at the end of the original movie. In the 2005 version Charlie “wins” the competition simply by not being eliminated due to bad behaviour like the other children.
I wonder if Charlie and the Chocolate Factory partially kind of marks a bit of a turning point for Burton movies for me. I love Beetlejuice and his Batman movies, and also enjoyed Sleepy Hollow, but I didn’t like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, and I also didn’t like Dark Shadows either. I haven’t seen Alice in Wonderland or Dumbo, but if they’re anything like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory then I’m not particularly interested.
5/10
After taking the family to see a matinee of Wonka last week I thought I’d show my kids the 1971 Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory which in my opinion is a classic with an iconic portrayal of Willy Wonka by Gene Wilder. My kids liked it, and the funny thing is my kids can’t pick up on sarcasm so my 8 year old son commented when we were done that Wilder’s Wonka was “such a nice man” lol.
In any event, I had never watched Tim Burton’s Charlie and the Chocolate Factory featuring Johnny Depp as Willy Wonka, so we watched it the other night. I hated everything about this movie. Depp and Burton have a long history of making movies together, most of which are good, but just nothing worked in this movie for me. I hated Depp’s portrayal of Wonka. Dude was a mentally ill creep with literal daddy issues and a patently obvious disdain for children. The new musical numbers for the Oompa Loompas were atrocious. Even the portrayals of the children weren’t as memorable. OG Veruca Salt was a world class cunt. The new one was just whiny. And the new Mike TV was a vicious little bastard.
Even the story wasn’t as good. I’ve heard the inclusion of Slugworth as red herring villain was something they added for the 1971 movie and wasn’t in the novel, but to me that was somewhat critical to the plot as it gave Charlie the opportunity to do something good to prove his trustworthiness and values by returning the everlasting gobstopper to Wonka at the end of the original movie. In the 2005 version Charlie “wins” the competition simply by not being eliminated due to bad behaviour like the other children.
I wonder if Charlie and the Chocolate Factory partially kind of marks a bit of a turning point for Burton movies for me. I love Beetlejuice and his Batman movies, and also enjoyed Sleepy Hollow, but I didn’t like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, and I also didn’t like Dark Shadows either. I haven’t seen Alice in Wonderland or Dumbo, but if they’re anything like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory then I’m not particularly interested.
5/10