Prime Jackie Chan vs. Prime Jet Li

[esum80]

inspired by this thread:
http://origin.forums.sherdog.com/th...s-prime-steven-seagal.3682759/#post-137088979

who takes it? jet or jackie?

 

[sirtapsalot]

Best Jackie Chan movies:
thunderbolt
rumble in the Bronx

Best Jet Li movies:
lethal weapon
romeo must die

Jackie Chan is clearly better

 

[ROKKO]

I think even Jet Li would acknowledge Jackie Chan's superiority.

I don't think he'd take it personal

 

[minute bull]

Best Jet Li movies:
lethal weapon
romeo must die

Did you catch FIST OF LEGEND?

 

[coopdro]

Going with Jet Li based on pure emotion when he fights. No slapstick with this man. He's on a mission to rock your world with all 5 feet of his prowess.

If Jackie has a nearby ladder though ... may be looking at a stalemate.

 

[Orgasmo]

In terms of acting? Jackie Chan by a country mile

In terms of being an accomplished martial artist? Jet Li easily

 

[Robocok]

Best Jackie Chan movies:
thunderbolt
rumble in the Bronx

Best Jet Li movies:
lethal weapon
romeo must die

Jackie Chan is clearly better

Drunken Master and Snake in the Eagle's Shadow are great too.

 

[Tee Dee Pee]

Best Jackie Chan movies:
thunderbolt
rumble in the Bronx

Best Jet Li movies:
lethal weapon
romeo must die

Jackie Chan is clearly better

You said thunderbolt...




stahp

 

[smooth assassin]

Jet Ri arrrrr day

 

[Frode Falch]

Jet li by being a true pure martial artist first and actor 2nd.

Jackie chan came from the opera school. Where they learned play fighting for using in plays on stage or in films.

Jackie was a better stunt man and acrobatic.

 

[sirtapsalot]

You said thunderbolt...




stahp

you're right I shouldn't have said best, I should've said movies I enjoyed most.

 

[Cheese]

 

[GSP_37]

I enjoy Jackie Chan's movies way better. Jet seems too serious and seems to use fake moves and wire work.

Donnie Yen would probably kick both their asses via MMA.

 

[AnGrYcRoW]

JC for the stunts alone

 

[zapataxiv]

Best Jackie Chan movies:
thunderbolt
rumble in the Bronx

Best Jet Li movies:
lethal weapon
romeo must die

Jackie Chan is clearly better

my god this list is so wrong..
i don't mean to be over dramatic but have you looked into chemical castration and or assisted suicide?

 

[LEGS MAHONEY]

I would pick Jackie. He strikes me as someone who would thumb you in the eye to get a win if things were not going his way.

 

[Phr3121]

Jet Li

 

[Phr3121]

Mark Dacascos.

 

[mb23100]

Love them both but gotta go with Jackie for sure. Probably the greatest stunt man ever while Jet uses wires and cgi too much

 

[RDUBYA]

my god this list is so wrong..
i don't mean to be over dramatic but have you looked into chemical castration and or assisted suicide?

He's trolling. He must be.

Jackie is the GOAT action star.

If you don't have Police Story in your top 5 action films or hold his on screen fights with the likes of Wei, Urquidez or Ken lo up against any "end fights" of any era you just don't know what you're watching.