POLL: Who are the top 5 NFL quarterbacks of all time?

[Philo-Publius]

Who are the top 5 NFL quarterbacks of all time?

 

[Prefect]

It gets so tight after Brady, Peyton, Rodgers, and Brees. The QB position might have the tightest top 10 in sports.

 

[kensei]

I've always been a Marino diehard fan.

 

[Based and White Pilled]

As someone who was a happy little kid in St. Louis watching the Greatest Show on Turf, it warms my heart that you included Warner and hurts me not to vote for him. If we're just looking at their best one or two seasons, he's up there with the greats. He obviously lacked the longevity and consistency necessary for a GOAT candidate, though.

Edit: I changed my vote to include him, just to show support.

 

[Bamboozled]

Otto Graham
Peyton Manning
Aaron Rodgers
Dan Marino
Johnny Unitas

Overrated cans with stacked rosters where defense won them championships need not apply

 

[Simple Southerner]

Brady
Manning
Montana
Elway
Marino

 

[Philo-Publius]

As someone who was a happy little kid in St. Louis watching the Greatest Show on Turf, it warms my heart that you included Warner and hurts me not to vote for him. If we're just looking at their best one or two seasons, he's up there with the greats. He obviously lacked the longevity and consistency necessary for a GOAT candidate, though.

Edit: I changed my vote to include him, just to show support.

He lacked longevity because he played in Arena football for years and was overlooked. He was an insane talent and managed to go to Super Bowls with two different franchises (that puts him in a very small club of NFL quarterbacks).

 

[Prefect]

Tarketon should be up there. He is top ten material.

 

[Razor]

Brady
Rodgers
Montana
Manning
Brees

 

[the ambush]

I will always vote for Montana, Brady & Peyton in polls like this.

 

[the ambush]

It gets so tight after Brady, Peyton, Rodgers, and Brees. The QB position might have the tightest top 10 in sports.

Agree with Brady & Peyton. Why no Montana though?

 

[Prefect]

Agree with Brady & Peyton. Why no Montana though?

You could make him five, along with lot of others. Montana doesn't have the same stats with the others but I would b hard pressed to say that he is worst.

 

[JackWhite]

1) Brady
2) Montana
3) P. Manning
4) Elway
5) Favre

 

[JSN]

Stephen A Smith says Russell Wilson should be considered # 1 because institutional racism and reparations n sheeit.

 

[smooth assassin]

Otto Graham
Peyton Manning
Aaron Rodgers
Dan Marino
Johnny Unitas

Overrated cans with stacked rosters where defense won them championships need not apply

As good as Marino was, he never one the big games
Truth be told it’s Hard to see him more deserving than his counterpart joe Montana

 

[Bamboozled]

As good as Marino was, he never one the big games
Truth be told it’s Hard to see him more deserving than his counterpart joe Montana

He also had a worse team

 

[rj144]

You could make him five, along with lot of others. Montana doesn't have the same stats with the others but I would b hard pressed to say that he is worst.

I'm a HUGE Brady fan, but you're nuts if you don't think Montana and Brady are not 1 and 2 in any order.

 

[Mondo Freaks]

Jeff Garcia
Jake Plummer
Kevin Kolb
Daunte Culpepper
Rex Grossman

 

[Makani]

Brady
Rodgers
Montana
Manning
Brees

Easy peasy, though I might switch the middle 3 around depending on the day.

 

[MrFeeny]

You could make him five, along with lot of others. Montana doesn't have the same stats with the others but I would b hard pressed to say that he is worst.

Stats are relative to the era. Montana would have similar stats to brady if he played in this post 2004 era. Marino and Fouts would have had similar stats to Brees and Manning.