Pasta w/ Tomato Sauce: You're Doing It Wrong

SFMMA

Brown Belt
@Brown
Joined
May 5, 2015
Messages
2,821
Reaction score
638
Pasta is hands down my favorite food. As such, I learned how to make it and have been cooking it for the past 15+ years. Nothing infuriates me more than going to a restaurant, ordering a $25+ plate of pasta, and then knowing in one bite that I can make much, much better for much, much less. I rarely order it any more for this very reason.

Real pasta with tomato/pomodoro sauce is easy as fuck and involves four or five simple ingredients: pasta, garlic, tomatoes, extra-virgin olive oil, and maybe basil. You prefer a slightly more complex marinara? Cool. Add some anchovies, parsley, white wine, and maybe some chili flakes and capers. Also easy as fuck. Let me break it down for you, my ninjas.

Tomatoes
Use only canned whole San Marzano or ripe plum tomatoes that are in season. Not Wholesome Choice Organic Bullshit Tomatoes w/ Italian Spices or January's half-ripe cardboard bullshit tomatoes from Senor Pepe's Meximart.

Garlic
This should be amazingly simple, but it's incredible how often I see people screw this up. If the garlic is old or has green shoots in it, don't use it. People also overcook the shit out of garlic. What happens when a piece of meat turns overly dark when you're cooking it? It turns bitter and you don't want to eat it. Same with garlic. When preparing it, smash a few bulbs, remove the skins, cut off the stems, sprinkle some kosher salt on top with a dash of oil, then finely mince. The salt will act as an abrasive and help break it down. Drag your blade over it a few times at a 10-15% angle, and repeat until you've got nearly a puree.

Extra-Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO)
"OMG, EVOO is totes expensive!" Get the fuck out of my kitchen. Extra-virgin olive oil is (usually) the first press, has a much better (fruity, grassy, etc.) flavor depending on the country and/or region, and also has a higher smoking point, which means less chance of making your sauce taste like a burned pile of shit.

Basil
Half the basil I see at the grocery store these days looks like nonna wiped her ass with it. Bruised, wilted, etc. Grow your own or make sure the stuff you buy at the market is pristine, but if it's an inferior product, you're going to have an inferior result. Add basil at the end of the cooking process, otherwise the fresh herbaceous quality will be lost and it will muddy the brightness of the tomatoes. There's a lot of argument between torn and chopped basil, without a lot of scientific evidence I've found to support either conclusively. I prefer torn because there tends to be less bruising during the chiffonade (slicing thin ribbons), even with a very sharp knife.

Pasta
Don't bother making pasta for this application. Sure, the homemade stuff is great for pillowy ravioli, toothsome tortellini, and fluffy gnocchi, but if we're talking spaghetti, bucatini, or linguine in red sauce, it's truly unnecessary. Many of the best restaurants in the world use the dry stuff.

Pasta w/ Tomato Sauce Recipe
Finally, JESUS.

Ingredients
  • 1 package dry spaghetti, bucatini, or linguine (in order of preference)
  • 2+ lbs good-quality tomatoes or 1 28 oz. can whole San Marzano tomatoes
  • 4-6 cloves garlic, finely minced
  • 2+ tablespoons of EVOO
  • fresh basil (optional)
  • Parmesan cheese (optional)
  • kosher salt, to taste
  • fresh cracked black pepper, to taste (optional)

1) Grab a few good tomatoes. If you're using canned whole San Marzano tomatoes, skip to step 2. I prefer this method, but tomatoes aren't always in season. We're creating what's called a concasse, which is a French technique for an Italian dish that basically means "crushed." Prepare an ice bath with plenty of ice and water and get a large pot of water boiling. Cut an "X" in the bottom of each tomato and remove the cores. Drop them in the boiling water for 20-45 seconds, or until they start to visibly wrinkle and peel. Remove them, preferably with a spider (mesh skimmer), and place them in the water bath until cool. This is called blanching. Peel the tomatoes, slice them in half, remove the seeds with your fingers (not all are necessary), and medium dice.

2) In a blender, pulse the canned whole San Marzano tomatoes a few times. You still want a bit of chunk.

3) Create a near-puree of garlic using the technique indicated under the "garlic" header.

4) Over medium-high heat in a wide sautee pan, heat a couple of healthy glugs of EVOO.

5) Add garlic to the pan with oil and a pinch of kosher salt, and stir 30-45 seconds. If the garlic gets dark at all (past golden), restart. The heat was too high.

6) Add your tomatoes and a healthy pinch of salt. Stir occasionally and never allow the heat to bring the mixture to more than a simmer. Very lightly simmer for no more than 40 minutes, less with canned tomatoes. With fresh tomatoes, you want the flesh of the tomatoes to have broken down and formed a thick, mostly smooth, unfiorm consistency. We will thin it a bit at the end.

7) A few minutes before your sauce is finished, cook your pasta in plenty of very salty, boiling water. You want a roiling boil and a good small handful of kosher salt. Stir occasionally so the starch can bounce around and the pasta doesn't stick together. Cook for one minute less than the required cooking time, which should be on the "too al dente" side of al dente.

8) Check your sauce for seasoning (kosher salt), add as necessary (vegetables usually need a healthy dose, and not all tomato batches are the same), and tear basil into it. If you're adding Parmesan cheese, remember that it will add a fair amount of saltiness to your dish.

9) Strain pasta, but not all the way. You want about scant 1/4 cup of that starchy water in your sauce to help the sauce adhere to the pasta. Pour your pasta and that bit of a water into the sauce. (If you're worried about pouring in too much water, simply reserve the water at the end in a container and add with the completely drained pasta.) Continue cooking the sauce over medium-high heat, and drag the pasta through to coat for about a minute.

10) This is where, if desired, you add your Parmesan cheese, which will also help bring the sauce together. Don't even think about shaking it out of a green bottle. Use that real shit and drop panties. I personally add a fuck ton, with a couple of glugs of EVOO and fresh-cracked black pepper.

11) Plating tip: Grag a pair of grill tongs (the kind with the scalloped edges), insert into pasta, and rotate 45 degrees. Release gently on your plate/bowl and it will create a neat swirl. Garnish a tiny drizzle of EVOO, a light blanket of Parmesan, and a floret or a few ribbons of basil.

Sorry if I just got you laid.

My knowledge of pasta isn't limited to this particular dish. I have created pretty much everything. If you've got any questions, ask away.
 
Why use canned tomatoes when you can just blanch some, peel them, and roast them in an iron skillet?
 
Why use canned tomatoes when you can just blanch some, peel them, and roast them in an iron skillet?
I just throw them in a blender with no prep and they're better than the ketchup TS makes.
 
lol @ "Not wanting to eat bitter garlic" when it is one of most complex, sought after flavors in asian and world cuisine.
 
lol @ "Not wanting to eat bitter garlic" when it is one of most complex, sought after flavors in asian and world cuisine.

You see a lot of spaghetti with tomato sauce in Asian cuisine, dipshit?

Also, crispy garlic =/= burned garlic. Crispy garlic comes from heating garlic in oil over an extended period of time and creates deep and nuanced flavor. Burned garlic comes from quickly overcooking garlic in too-hot oil and creates a flavor akin to what I assume you look for in a woman. Wind your neck in, you clueless simpleton.
 
Tomato sauce is better with onion and carrot. The sweetness of both makes it much better. Suck it.
 
You see a lot of spaghetti with tomato sauce in Asian cuisine, dipshit?

Also, crispy garlic =/= burned garlic. Crispy garlic comes from heating garlic in oil over an extended period of time and creates deep and nuanced flavor. Burned garlic comes from quickly overcooking garlic in too-hot oil and create a flavor similar to your mom's rancid cooze. Wind your neck in, you clueless simpleton.

"Burned" garlic is fucking delicious in pork or fish based stocks. You didn't specify that "bitter" garlic doesn't work in tomato sauce.
And some would argue that it does. I like my sauce hearty, smokey and bitter. Some (most) people like it sweet. People who don't know shit about food. Like you.
 
Tomato sauce is better with onion and carrot. The sweetness of both makes it much better. Suck it.

Hey, to each their own. That's one way to do it. I'm guessing you prefer your BBQ sauce super sweet?
 
Why use canned tomatoes when you can just blanch some, peel them, and roast them in an iron skillet?
Did you watch jaime oliver when he went italy and every region he went they all make pasta sauce different and each one insulted the other claiming their way was best and if you deviate or fusion a recipe they spit on it and say its not real and its bad . They sound a lot like ts .
 
So TS only ate pasta for the past 15+ years and still ordered it when he went out... You must be a religious man...
flyingspaghettimonstervinci.jpg
 
"Burned" garlic is fucking delicious in pork or fish based stocks. You didn't specify that "bitter" garlic doesn't work in tomato sauce.
And some would argue that it does. I like my sauce hearty, smokey and bitter. Some (most) people like it sweet. People who don't know shit about food. Like you.

My exact words in OP were: "It turns bitter and you don't want to eat it."

You're doing a great job continuing to prove yourself wrong.

Also, stop whining like a little bitch. This thread is to HELP people create better red sauce and/or pasta dishes, not for ass clowns to come out of the woodwork to offer intriguing conversation pieces like "shut up." If you disagree with me, use your big boy words.
 
Great write up. One item I question though.

Extra-Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO)
"OMG, EVOO is totes expensive!" Get the fuck out of my kitchen. Extra-virgin olive oil is (usually) the first press, has a much better (fruity, grassy, etc.) flavor depending on the country and/or region, and also has a higher smoking point, which means less chance of making your sauce taste like a burned pile of shit.

It's my understanding all the complexity of organic chemicals that makes EVOO more flavorful and healthy, has a negative effect on smoking point.
I believe that cheaper, refined Olive Oil actually has a higher smoking point, and is superior for high heat applications.

Otherwise excellent read.
 
Did you watch jaime oliver when he went italy and every region he went they all make pasta sauce different and each one insulted the other claiming their way was best and if you deviate or fusion a recipe they spit on it and say its not real and its bad . They sound a lot like ts .
lol no, TS sounds like a housewife who just watched a Jaime Oliver Christmas special and thinks he's going to bag a hot girl with his tomato sauce recipe.
 
Did you watch jaime oliver when he went italy and every region he went they all make pasta sauce different and each one insulted the other claiming their way was best and if you deviate or fusion a recipe they spit on it and say its not real and its bad . They sound a lot like ts .

The spit makes it extra spicy!!

And I think they ate fish based cuisine in Sicily, right? I think it was Sicily. I remember watching that ep and that he got accepted into the highly critical chef cult with his own dish.
 
Back
Top