P4P hardest hitters of all time each weight class

1

120wrestling

Brown Belt
@Brown
Joined
Aug 8, 2015
Messages
3,822
Reaction score
0
Fighters who have competed in multiple weight classes will be judged with the weight class they have had their most success in. This only includes one punch power

Flyweight
- John Dodson

Bantamweight
- John Lineker

Featherweight
- Chad Mendes

Lightweight
- Melvin Guillard

Welterweight
- Manhoef

Middleweight
- Dan Henderson

Light Heavyweight
- Rampage (Would put Rumble, but Rampage has KO's over Wanderlei, Lidell, Randleman, Arona, Eastman, etc..)

Heavyweight
- Mark Hunt

Who would you put and where?

EDIT: Could replace Mendes with McG
 
Middleweight: Left hook Larry.
 
I agree with ur picks except Gomi for LW and Conor for FW

And Humble doesnt hit harder than Hampage. Chuck was known for his chin pre Hampage , damn near knocked him out with a punch counter not even loaded up then one of the GNP shots put him out cold. Gus and a Nog who didn't have the chin he used to weren't even out cold from his shots and he needed multiple shots

Rumble has pretty much only knocked welterweights out cold. He had bader his last fight who was KOd stiff by Lyoto a MW and who got damn near KOd by fucking Tito lmao

Jimi is the only other noteworthy one and he seems to have a shaky chin

Rumble couldn't knockout Arlovski who's known for being chinny @ HW. Hampage KOd Randleman the first clean shot he got and broke Igor's ribs with body shots forcing him to basically give up
 
Melvin Manhoef can't have fought many of his fights at WW so he doesn't seem a good representation of that weight class. I might replace Hendo with him at MW instead, although it's hard to pick between the two (the Hunt KO is what makes me lean to Manhoef). At WW it might be pre USADA Hendricks.
 
Also Ellenberger deserves HM for WW and his body of work at the weight trumps Melvin

- Dropped and nearly KOd Carlos if not for a clutch knee to the body that stifled followup, hurt him multiple times and more than anyone ever with Carlos arguably having the GOAT chin @ WW, arguably the only guy to 10-8 Carlos
- KOd Shields unconscious and had him wrestling with the ref (same Shields a couple fights ago who took 2 H Bombs to the dome and was dropped, yet came back to 10-8 Hendo and dominate the rest of the fight
- KOd Marquardt dead
- dropped and nearly KOd Kampmann on the 1st exchange
- dropped Wonderboy and made him go stiff for a moment
- hurt Tarec multiple times badly where his movement completely froze
- KOd Piearson and Pyle

etc.. dude had and still has that retard power, shame he never put his game together consistently
 
Last edited:
Squarechoke said:
Melvin Manhoef can't have fought many of his fights at WW so he doesn't seem a good representation of that weight class. I might replace Hendo with him at MW instead, although it's hard to pick between the two (the Hunt KO is what makes me lean to Manhoef). At WW it might be pre USADA Hendricks.
Click to expand...

Yeah I always thought of Manhoef as a mw. But Im pretty sure a perfect h bomb from Henderson would ko Hunt too.
 
Bantamweight : Ronda rousey

Mayweather - "who? Never heard of him"
 
gmr7494 said:
Hw: Brock Lesnar by a mile
Click to expand...

FMYuXfw.gif
 
ExitLUPin said:
Also Ellenberger deserves HM for WW and his body of work at the weight trumps Melvin

- Dropped and nearly KOd Carlos if not for a clutch knee to the body that stifled followup, hurt him multiple times
- KOd Shields unconscious and had him wrestling with the ref (same Shields a couple fights ago who took 2 H Bombs to the dome and was dropped, yet came back to 10-8 Hendo and dominate the rest of the fight
- KOd Marquardt dead
- dropped and nearly KOd Kampmann on the 1st exchange
- dropped Wonderboy and made him go stiff for a moment
- hurt Tarec multiple times badly where his movement completely froze
- KOd Piearson and Pyle

etc.. dude had and still has that retard power, shame he never put his game together consistently
Click to expand...

Actually, I really wanted to put Jake Ellenberger in at WW...with potentially having the Old Hendricks in as well. I didn't know if Jake would go over well with everyone when I considered that Manhoef competed at WW and KO'd Hunt
 
120wrestling said:
Actually, I really wanted to put Jake Ellenberger in at WW...with potentially having the Old Hendricks in as well. I didn't know if Jake would go over well with everyone when I considered that Manhoef competed at WW and KO'd Hunt
Click to expand...

Hendricks was too inconsistent IMO. When he was on he was a motherfucker but hed go one fight from sending Kampmann or Fitch flying to his shots not doing much to Pierce or Kos.

He relied too much on those bursts to gather power, u see in his knockouch or when he rocked GSP he had to gather a full burst to put all his power into those shots.

With Jake he doesnt need to gather or load up to have that retard power stiffen and KO guys. He can be stationary and do the same. He had more power than Johnny for sure.
 
I'd put my boy BJ Penn for lightweight and, to me, Chuck is still the hardest hitter in LHW division history.
At HW, it is a tossup between Nelson, Hunt, and Dos Santos.
 
Ajidar said:
I'd put my boy BJ Penn for lightweight and, to me, Chuck is still the hardest hitter in LHW division history.
At HW, it is a tossup between Nelson, Hunt, and Dos Santos.
Click to expand...

BJ had great power but i dont see how u can put him over Gomi, Stephens, Melvin etc.... Even Dustin right now is a harder hitter than BJ was IMO.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,254,638
Messages
56,661,548
Members
175,336
Latest member
Swamps

Share this page

Back
Top