- Joined
- Oct 30, 2004
- Messages
- 92,559
- Reaction score
- 28,337
Didn't they do very well in their response by being extremely strict?
Don't know anything about Taiwan and COVID. Looks like Japan did well with the disease, looks like. They took some early steps and had some advantages (like a pre-existing culture of mask wearing). This line of the discussion started when someone was claiming that stronger gov't responses were no more effective at stemming the spread of the disease but led to worse economic outcomes. I'm not aware of any evidence to support the economic part of that claim (it looks like the public took precautions even when their gov'ts did, meaning that the spread of the disease was the factor hurting the economy). As far as the virus itself, it's obvious that factors beyond gov't response affected the spread, but I'd be cautious about concluding from that the gov't response was irrelevant.
Anyway, it's a complicated issue, and getting the right answers here are important because it's certainly possible that something like that could happen again (and of course even though we're talking about it in the past tense, it's not over, especially in some other countries), and we want to use the experience to inform a future response. But people are too caught up in hackery to even think about making a good-faith effort to understand reality.