This is more a matter of the UFC having a lot more depth in most of the divisions, rather than a matter of these guys not being legit. The UFC has more depth in their divisions to prove their legitimacy and a longer path to the title, whereas in Bellator you are always a couple of fights away from a titleshot. However, not being a champ in the UFC does not equate being a scrub or not being a top fighter. Mousasi, for example, was screwed out of a couple of title-shots and could have been very possibly been champ.
Now I'm responding to the Moraes comment but also everything else:
- On Moraes, yeah he's good for sure. Good name drop, but still he's not even a champion in the UFC after 7 fights. He went undefeated in an org with far less competition and quality (WSOF) and came to the UFC and lost to Assuncao immediately then went on a nice run. Similar to Alvarez from Bellator. But he lost to Cejudo and arguably lost to a semi-washed Aldo.
So yeah he's good but he's not some awesome example of how other orgs stockpile all these talent that's "secretly better than the UFC!" as people suggest. He alone does not make the narrative and idea true, even if he arguably as singular case is world class/UFC elite
There's a few examples of guys here and there that can compete in the top 5-10 probably, maybe even be elite or champions. But the examples are few and far between if they aren't in the UFC, that's the simple reality of it. Outside of Pride, WEC, Strikeforce...since then and even Strikeforce less so, it just simply doesn't exist.
Here's a list of names of studs from other orgs since then: Eddie Alvarez, Ben Askren, Justin Gaethje, Marlon Moraes, Will Brooks, Hector Lombard, etc.
Yeah one real belt between them all, one interim belt as well. Some success, some duds, Mostly mixed even with the most successful like Alvarez and Gaethje.
Here's a list of some names that were decent in the UFC but were studs in Bellator/other: Gegard Mousasi, Ryan Bader, Phil Davis, Matt Mitrione, Chieck Kongo, ~Rory McDonald (belt), etc.
Yeah guys who had some success but were never elite outside McDonald, having way more success in Bellator than the UFC in a very clear trend. Hmm I wonder why.