If Ngannou convincingly beats Gane, then Stipe, is he the GOAT?

[laz0001]

He could easily achieve that within 12 months.

No. He needs to go on a ten year undefeated streak to be the GOAT.

 

[MartinGibson86]

According to your logic the fastest man in the world Usain Bolt isn't the fastest man in the world 'cause he no longer runs at the same speed he used to, despite the fact his record still remains.

That is literally the exact argument you are using.

MMA has evolved more in the last 30 years than running has...well...ever.


That's a realy stupid comparison.

Mark Coleman literally placed both palms on the mat behind Fedor's head. He might as well have screamed "Armbar me!!"


But he did beat Severn for a ufc title. So thats definitely a better win than Bones over Vera.

Kevin Randleman shot directly into a standing guillotind from a fuckn kicknoxer the fight after Fedor. Never won a meaningful fight after Fedor and had dropped 2 of 3prior.


Fotmer ufc champ tho... so a better win than Bones over Bader


wow

 

[MartinGibson86]

No. He needs to go on a ten year undefeated streak to be the GOAT.

Jason Reinhardt went on like a 7 year undefeated streak

 

[Gamer2k4]

Nope.

Greatest of "ALL TIME" is your clue.

"All time" obviously means "all time that's happened so far." It's beyond pedantic to act as though that's not the case.

When someone says, "A New Hope is the shortest Star Wars movie," do you say, "Nuh uh, they might make another Star Wars movie that's shorter"? When someone says, "Tom Brady has the most Superbowl rings," do you say, "Nuh uh, someone else might get more in the future"? Obviously any comparison ever has the inherent assumption that you can only compare things that exist, and not things that don't.

I only hope you're just trying to LOOK like an idiot for the sake of "trolling," and that you're not actually this foolish.

 

[MartinGibson86]

Hed have to win a few big fights after that to be in the talk of being above fedor

Already has more big fight wins than Fedor.

 

[Emjay]

"All time" obviously means "all time that's happened so far." It's beyond pedantic to act as though that's not the case.

Not everyone sees it that way

 

[cws80us]

Dude hasn't even defended yet and folks already taking goat.. unbelievable. The bar just keeps getting lower and lower