If Bisping defeats Weidman and Jacare is he the greatest MW ever?

[TSDouglas]

Best ever? No.

Anderson ruled forever and you cant really compare the times. Andersons opponents were the best at that time.

Also, Anderson in his prime destroys Bisping. Just murks him.

He murked him in they're fight and still lost the decision lol

 

[TSDouglas]

Bisping would at least 5 more wins with that belt to be considered. IMO

 

[Mixedfights]

He murked him in they're fight and still lost the decision lol

"Anderson in his prime"

 

[Jon Stark]

Best ever? No.

Anderson ruled forever and you cant really compare the times. Andersons opponents were the best at that time.

Also, Anderson in his prime destroys Bisping. Just murks him.

And probably wins 9/10 times now! Silva gave away the 4th round and could have probably won the 1st if he didn't show off. Good on him for losing but I still feel Bisping only truly won round 2. He won 1 and 4 but Silva GAVE him those rounds.

 

[Mr Wings]

Straight trollin'. lol to all of you who took this post

Half of those defenses he ran like the whole time. Cote, Leites, and especially Maia were the worst fights in championship history. Plus I have no reason to believe he wasn't juiced to the tits the entire time. Bisping just dominated Anderson, if he can continue to beat the new breed of fighters along with owning many UFC records I say he has a better case than Anderson or Franklin. And yeah I started this thread just to watch it blowup.

As has been pointed out, about half of his opponents got busted for PEDs at some point, so if you're going to throw around the assumption that Anderson was juicing the whole time, we might as well call it even and say half his opponents were too.

I'm well aware of the Côte fight, I was there live. It doesn't matter that much if he ran during some of his title defenses; He won. Other times he beat his opponents to ever living death.

"IF IF IF"....Gotta love these noob "IF" threads. Let's get to reality. Silva was a great win for Bisping, but that was not champion Silva, it was old man Silva. The Rockhold win was fantastic. Let's not blow our loads and start calling a guy who has not yet defended the title "GOAT."

 

[ZackZed]

Much like you being as good as your last fight.

Bingo!