If Amanda wins, would you consider her the best female bantamweight in UFC history?

[RoyalG]

She beat Valentina
She beat Tate
Ronda is the next


The problem is: she beat Tate in her worst shape. And probably Ronda won't be in her best mindset.
What is your opinion?

 

[Willek]

Bethe.

 

[Headkicktoleg]

She will go down in as the best champ in the long and storied history of WBW

 

[Oliver Clothesoff]

Not yet.

 

[War Pig]

She'll have to defend the title at least 6 times and finish all of her opponents in the 1st round.

 

[benebox]

Depends, probably would be with another couple of wins.

 

[wonderbread]

close

 

[mikedanton]

She beat Miesha a lot quicker than Ronda could. If she beats Ronda in round 1 then yes that argument could be made.

 

[method115]

She hasn't done nearly enough yet. At least defend the title a few times then we can talk.

 

[MMA4Life]

She beat Valentina
She beat Tate
Ronda is the next


The problem is: she beat Tate in her worst shape. And probably Ronda won't be in her best mindset.
What is your opinion?

It would be too soon she doesn't have 10 fight win streak or anything like that in the UFC yet.

 

[TheGrouch]

The division has been around for like 10 minutes lol...

 

[Talon81]

Some day people will learn that beating the best ever does not make you the best ever. It takes longevity. Every time someone defends (or in Conors case before he even won) a title some idiot posts about GOAT or best ever. Stfu. Ronda and Aldo had lots of defenses. Beating them makes one better than them AT THAT TIME but FAR from GOAT talks.

When you successfully defend a title 7 or 8 times, or at least like 4 times against superior challengers, then you become a candidate

 

[Dogo1]

Not until she a bunch of 1st round defenses

 

[ocs2304]

She beat Miesha a lot quicker than Ronda could. If she beats Ronda in round 1 then yes that argument could be made.

No, this is just stupid, I dislike RR as much as the next person but wake the fuck up morons

 

[Drunk Bum]

Good old Sherdog, any new champ no matter who it is becomes "Greatest said champ in said division history"

You'll jump off the wagon when Ronda armbars her, watch.

 

[djason1988]

Well, women's bw doesn't have much history, so that title doesn't count for much. For what it's worth though, it's still Ronda

 

[mikedanton]

No, this is just stupid, I dislike RR as much as the next person but wake the fuck up morons

Ronda's best win is against Tate. If Amanda wins then how can Ronda be the best in the division's short history?

 

[The guest]

No.

 

[Thepaintbucket]

Nah. She needs to redeem herself against Cat and then defend it a few times against the Beths of the division.

 

[ColombianFist]

Not yet, TS.

Too soon.