Impossibile to say, both had their peak in different years.That photo still makes me sad.
Shinichi Shinohara>>>>>>>>David Douillet.
Great misjudgement in sport's history.
Douillet had his peak in 1996.
Shinohara in 2000.
A fight between a 1996 Douillet vs a 2000 Shinohara, I don't know how would it end.