GSP vs Silva - A size difference or a skill difference?

my2hungeeSX97 said:
Yes superfights are bad for the sport and can potentially destroy a fighters career

The fight before the 2 fights with Edgar was the "superfight" (LW Penn vs WW GSP)
After the superfight Penn was never the same

Superfights are only wanted by the WWE turned MMA fan

"True" mma fans like myself would never want a superfight between because "true" mma fans recognize that it can destroy a fighter's career (the loser)

MMA "fans" need to stop been so selfish and actually show respect to MMA fighters even ones that are not "big names"
Click to expand...

Most people want to see the super fight, bj isn't considered mediocre he is one of the best of all time, after the gsp fight he wasnt considered p4p king but he was still great, he fell from it when he lost to edgar . I haven't watched wwe since I was a little kid I still want to see a super fight and so does everyone else, stop it with this real fan BS.
 
my2hungeeSX97 said:
Yes superfights are bad for the sport and can potentially destroy a fighters career

The fight before the 2 fights with Edgar was the "superfight" (LW Penn vs WW GSP)
After the superfight Penn was never the same

Superfights are only wanted by the WWE turned MMA fan

"True" mma fans like myself would never want a superfight between because "true" mma fans recognize that it can destroy a fighter's career (the loser)

MMA "fans" need to stop been so selfish and actually show respect to MMA fighters even ones that are not "big names"
Click to expand...

After the superfight Penn actually looked great against Sanchez and Florian.

Also Penn's rivalry with GSP and Hughes is one of the highlights of his career.

Why not just ban title fights since it can destroy a fighter's career too.
 
Everyone knows Silva has superior skills. Especially GSP and his fans despite them being in denial about it.
 
lol I find it funny how GSP fans think it's some type of size mismatch now when a couple years ago they used to brag about how GSP would dominate Silva with takedowns and would cite GSP outwrestling Rashad in training as proof that GSP would be able to take Silva down at will.
 
Both. That's why this fight makes no sense. Silva is bigger and better.
 
To remove the size part the fight should be at 170.
 
Brock2026 said:
The size difference is minimal.
Except the height.

Striking - Silva significantly
Clinch - Silva (Muay Thai) and GSP (Greco-Roman)
Wrestling - GSP significantly
Top Game Grappling - GSP
Bottom Game Grappling - Silva
Finishing Capability - Silva (But I think this is mainly due to style. Striking is designed to KO/TKO somebody but wrestling is more about control)

My opinion.
Click to expand...

It is nothing but minimal.
 
Bargey said:
Everyone knows Silva has superior skills. Especially GSP and his fans despite them being in denial about it.
Click to expand...

I really wish people that are Silva fans would stop talking like this. As a Silva fan, it's an embarrassment. As a GSP fan who wants this fight to happen, it's simply astounding due to your level of ignorance.

I absolutely, positively want this fight to happen. I really do want to see who the greatest fighter in the world today is, and a win for either guy is essentially the guarantee that their legacy will be cemented as the greatest fighter in the world in their time. I think GSP has all the skills to beat Anderson. His MMA wrestling is the best in the game, his takedowns are the best in UFC history, and he knows enough BJJ to not get caught in a triangle the way Sonnen did. He's also probably the most intelligent fighter in terms of fight IQ.

Now I'm also a Silva fan, and I know this is a tough match up for GSP due to Silva's other-worldly striking. He combines things that no one else can combine; he fights like no one else can fight, and takes your soul in the process. And that's why I want to see if GSP can solve the Silva puzzle, or if Silva can simply assert his dominance and add GSP's soul to his collection.

It's all unknown, and I really, really want to find out. So please, do not assume that all GSP fans are making excuses for why this fight shouldn't happen or make asinine demands like make the fight at 170. It's not even up to the fans how this fight does or does not happen, it's up to the UFC and the fighters and their trainers and camps. We don't really have a say in who fights who, I mean Chael Sonnen is fucking fighting Jon Jones!
 
Groundmaster said:
Unheard of, the fighter challenged is not ready to fight at the challengers WC. A scandal! Ohh wait AS told Rua to move down to 185 when Shogun expressed desire in fighting him after he took the belt from Machida.




See above. Dork.
Click to expand...

177.5 is not a weight class, you are full of crap.
 
markg171 said:
The people who don't want to see a potential GSP/Silva fight - is it because of a potential size difference or a perceived skill difference?

Potential size difference?
silva-gsp2-300x206.jpg


Or skill difference?
silva-griffin.gif


gsp_alves_takedown.gif
Click to expand...

It's clearly skill

GSP knows the only way he could beat Anderson is to turn into Ubereem and pray he could go out there and hold him down for 3-5 rounds.

Skill wise GSP would be a fool to trade with Anderson. GSP's striking is good but Anderson is a master. Anderson doesn't care about take downs. GSP is not a finisher on the ground and that leaves Anderson always in the fight to come back and KO him at any given time.

Anderson is just too deadly for GSP, that's the real reason he doesn't want to fight. Anderson is accurate, he punches , kicks and knees with KO power. GSP's entire game plan would be to avoid the fire power. That's not the same GSP. He can no longer set up jabs and kicks without fear of being countered to sleep, which is Anderson specialty.

GSP wins round and his specialty is getting that take down to eat up the clock. GSP basis his strategies on over powering people at 170 most of the time and using 50 percent of the skills he's trained for that's the problem. I have yet to see him go all out and that's what it will take against Anderson. Anderson unlike most MMA fighters has beyond patience, the ability to blue print a fighter and the skill to capitalize of one mistake, a bad movement or reaction and end the fight. GSP see's this as the rest of the logical people.

It's a major risk for him to fight Anderson. There is no doubt GSP can get a take down but after what Silva has been through and what he does to people that shouldn't make you confident at all. People think GSP doesn't have any holes in his game but he's not a finisher and he leaves the door open.
 
The size difference is the reason why GSP would be to small at 185 and ironically Andy would be to small at 170 to compete against GSP.....ain't life grand?
 
R0bert0Lu0ng0 said:
Anderson doesnt want to fight for the belt at 205 because he has teammates at 205.
He said it tons of times. You blind or something?
Click to expand...

If you believe that i got a bridge that is for sale.. Beat Jones then drop the belt.. Or make the fight a 205 non title fight... The UFC can do whatever they want..
 
Do people saying skills really think that Silva would beat GSP at 170?

Not sure of that.
 
Last edited:
In terms of skill they are very close. GSP has no real holes in his game.. Nothing that is obvious to attack.. Silva is the better striker and has a better offensive JJ game but GSP has amazing sub defense, and the best wrestling in MMA.. GSP is good everywhere..
 
Obviously a size difference, or Anderson could make 170 as easily as GSP. But the size difference is about ten pounds, which is significant but not unsurmountable.

In terms of skills, GSP has better wrestling, Anderson has better striking, probably about the same BJJ skills for both.

With the combo of skill difference and size difference, GSP will probably lose.

Of course, that seems to be true all around. Bendo would probably lose to GSP. GSP would probably lose to Anderson. Anderson would probably lose to Jones. Jones would probably lose to JDS.

Size matters, despite all those Kung-fu movies which says it doesn't. GSP knows this, which is why he wants the fight at 170. Anderson knows this, which is why he wants to fight GSP first instead of Jones. Jones knows this, which is why he isn't fighting HW.
 
georgejjr said:
Obviously a size difference, or Anderson could make 170 as easily as GSP. But the size difference is about ten pounds, which is significant but not unsurmountable.

In terms of skills, GSP has better wrestling, Anderson has better striking, probably about the same BJJ skills for both.

With the combo of skill difference and size difference, GSP will probably lose.

Of course, that seems to be true all around. Bendo would probably lose to GSP. GSP would probably lose to Anderson. Anderson would probably lose to Jones. Jones would probably lose to JDS.

Size matters, despite all those Kung-fu movies which says it doesn't. GSP knows this, which is why he wants the fight at 170. Anderson knows this, which is why he wants to fight GSP first instead of Jones. Jones knows this, which is why he isn't fighting HW.
Click to expand...

Pretty much true all the way around except Jones will fight at HW eventually and GSP at MW eventually IMO..
 
Size. And that picture isn't nearly accurate. It'll look worse than Condit/GSP squaring off at weigh-ins.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,283,165
Messages
58,485,646
Members
176,049
Latest member
YouKnowJman

Share this page

Back
Top