Greatest of All Time update

[servel20]

Silva would beat Fedor in open weight now or 5 years ago. The bias is strong here.

Indeed the bias is strong.

6ft 2in 185lbs "middleweight" Anderson Silva getting subbed twice in Prime Fedor era by 5ft 8in and 5ft 9in 170 pounders.

Yet in your dimwitted head he would have a chance against the guy who was wrecking guys like Coleman, prime Cro Cop and fresh big Nog.

c'mon son, not even Anderson himself would agree with you.

 

[Perrichet]

Silva would beat Fedor in open weight now or 5 years ago. The bias is strong here.

The irony of this post is strong

 

[Tchernobog]

Weidman loss changed the game in the minds of many, but not mine: AS is still GOAT.

 

[Break Brick]

how do you check who voted for who?

Edit nevermind figured it out

 

[TheComebackKid]

And don't forget TRT user.

Some of us don't give a shot about that

 

[Armbars]

Other;

Jose Aldo

 

[Chinballs]

 

[Fraser B]

1/2/3 is split between Fedor/Anderson/GSP, ordered by whoever you like more.
4/5/6 is split between Hughes/Nog/Hendo, ordered by whoever you like more.

Nobody else is close.

Yeah this is exactly the way I see it. You really can't put 1-3 and 4-6 in order. It's like trying to pick a lhw goat between Chuck, Wand, Shogun, Rampage, and Jones.

 

[Deleted member 428241]

Indeed the bias is strong.

6ft 2in 185lbs "middleweight" Anderson Silva getting subbed twice in Prime Fedor era by 5ft 8in and 5ft 9in 170 pounders.

Yet in your dimwitted head he would have a chance against the guy who was wrecking guys like Coleman, prime Cro Cop and fresh big Nog.

c'mon son, not even Anderson himself would agree with you.

lol and fedor got submitted once and ko

 

[supernova]

lol and fedor got submitted once and ko

 

[Mufasatheking]

LOL 8D

You really think 6ft 2in 185 "middleweight" Anderson Silva would have any chance vs. A 5ft 11.5in 225lbs heavyweight destroyer prime Fedor?

You my friend are out of your mind, Fedor would take down Anderson and put a beating on him worse than he did Mark Coleman.

Fedor never "put a beating" on Coleman

 

[Mufasatheking]

1.Anderson
2/3. Fedor/GSP
4. Bones

Dont care about the rest

 

[supernova]

Fedor never "put a beating" on Coleman

Fedor fucked his face up so bad that Coleman's daughters were crying.


Do you even watch bro?

 

[supernova]

 

[Insmoke]

Prime Fedor would beat any version of Anderson in an open weight fight. The man was an absolute animal with virtually no weaknesses.

 

[Shoguns Prodigy**]

Goat says the Goat is BJ and i believe him.

 

[Mufasatheking]

Fedor fucked his face up so bad that Coleman's daughters were crying.


Do you even watch bro?

eh, it wasnt *that* bad, not like GSP post Condit. Little girls cry over everything.

One random point id like to say is that Fedor seems more genuinely humble, if Anderson didnt act like a dick in the Maia and Weidman fights and won them like he should have I think this poll would be skewed more in favour for anderson.

 

[Jermei]

Dan Henderson? Dafuq?

You don't know who Dan Henderson is

 

[Rozwell]

[YT]PCvWiBZusFE[/YT]

 

[Styrock]

Yeah, he's only got a victory over the guy that most people on Sherdog feel is the GOAT. And by the way, Dan had to drink water before stepping on the scales to MAKE HW for that fight FFS. I love how Fedor apologists point to Fedor not cutting weight as part of their argument for his GOAT status, without admitting that he lost to a fucking MW.

Fedor had a great five year run. But for the other half of his decade of going without a loss, he was fighting guys WAY outside the top 10.

And he lost three times in a row at a younger age than Anderson lost to Weidman FFS.

Dan isn't the GOAT. Neither is Fedor.

Blah Blah, but <insert a bunch of defeasible and statistical arguments against Anderson Silva> and it looks like that AS shouldn't even be mentioned in this thread.

And he lost three times in a row at a younger age than Anderson lost to Weidman FFS.

Hahaha stop being silly. Frankly, this is one of the most pathetic attempts to discredit a fighter ever.