Greatest film director?

Greatest film director?


  • Total voters
    138
He's not Spielberg, but another great director who is like this that I don't think I've seen mentioned is Danny Boyle.

MV5BMTc2NTU0ODQ0M15BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwNjYzMzc5Mg@@._V1_UY317_CR10,0,214,317_AL_.jpg


Trainspotting
Slumdog Millionaire
28 Days Later
127 Hours
Millions
Steve Jobs
Sunshine
Trance

That's a nice collection. 1 first 4 on the list are home runs. And he got a big name actress to not only go full frontal but to do it sans merkin and wood floor style.
 
Except that popularity was just one of the pillars we were discussing. Bay's films don't register with serious appeal; not even with the people who enjoy them most. That's why he doesn't sniff the Top #250 after time settles in.
However I feel that you weigh popularity in proportion to whatever best supports your original premise that most people don't enjoy Tarkovsky and Bergman. I will agree that they are less accessible, but I don't think they are to a degree that most people will tune out like some cinematic equivalent to James Joyce. Even if that were the case, I don't find it to really disagree with what I value most. I don't necessarily think a more universal appeal means better.
 
What I like about Kubrick is that he has absolute classics in various genres. Granted this is just what I've seen over the years and don't have official polls to back it up.

Full Metal Jacket is widely considered top 3-5 war movies.
2001 is one of the greatest sci-fi films.
The Shining is possibly the GOAT horror movie.
A Clockwork Orange is the king of avante-garde cinema.
Dr. Strangelove is a classic of satire/comedy.

Nobody calls Eyes Wide Shut a classic but it's a powerful relationship drama.
The period piece Barry Lyndon seems to gain more credibility all the time.
 
Real difficult.
First that comes to mind
is Kurosawa. Then I remember
Kubrick; then Bergman
& Scorcese. Von Trier is
closing in on honorable
mention & so is pt anderson.

Idk.
I'll say Kurosawa.
But I might be wrong.
 
No, Hitchcock is not anyone's Tom Clancy, but these guys have their value, too. Gripping accessibility is a must for most, and many storytellers who favor this emotional mode are every bit as timeless-- and often much more so-- than their more abstruse counterparts. Perhaps there is no greater example of this from more recent history than Alexander Dumas.

Kurosawa has proven to resonate with the mainstream (across cultures and time) in a way that Tarkovsky and Bergman never could. If I showed Seven Samurai in the public square in my hometown it would be a smash hit. People would adore it. Even rednecks adore Kurosawa. Only those who can't read subtitles might leave, and even then they might still stay. That's how powerful Kurosawa's stuff was to every viewer. If I projected a Bergman film I would lose like half or two thirds of the audience (I predict the well-studied Christians would stay). If I projected a Tarkovsky film there would be like me and one other guy in the grass at the end of the movie. You have to appreciate that many don't interpret cryptic cerebralism as good storytelling, and they don't identify with it.

Hitchcock and Kurosawa were both accessible and dense at the same time. Bergman and Tarkovsky were mostly just dense.
Underrated post itt imo
 
Needs more Hayao Miyazaki and Wes Anderson
Wes Anderson isnt in the echelon of "best ever" film directors and Myazaki is arguably not even top 5 japanese directors.

So no? It doesnt
 
Robert Zemeckis never gets enough love in these threads. He might not be the best but he should at least be on the list.

I just walked The Walk the other night. I had no interest in seeing it and kept wondering what could possibly be so interesting about a high wire walker, even if he did walk across the twin towers? But you know, it was pretty good. A lot better than I expected.

But Zemeckis has made several great movies. Back to the Future, Forrest Gump, Contact, Who Framed Roger Rabbit, Castaway, Flight, The Walk, Romancing the Stone, etc.
 
Who is the greatest movie director?

Other directors worth noting.....

Ingmar Bergman
Danny Boyle
Frank Capra
Ethan Coen, Joel Coen
Frank Darabont
Brian De Palma
Clint Eastwood
Federico Fellini
John Ford
Milos Forman
John Huston
Alejandro G. Iñárritu
Peter Jackson
Sidney Lumet
Hayao Miyazaki
Roman Polanski
Rob Reiner
Orson Welles
Robert Zemeckis

Fritz Lang
Luis Bunel
Jean Renoir
Jean Luc Godard
Robert Altman
 
Back
Top