Yes, it is "stupid". One of the biggest gripes Trump supporters think this election should be about is getting back manufacturing jobs that are dying off. Like I mentioned machinery is replacing labor every day with that and it ultimately will made it a non-issue. But continue to complain and act like we can fight against technological advances and free market decisions by both the companies AND consumers which you ignore.
1.40 instead of 1.00 for widget. You claim people wouldn't care but that's a flat out lie. People completely know the products they buy today. It's thrown in our faces each and every day what company uses china and its still labeled. Plus, we have companies that advertise "Made in USA". Why haven't cosumers all flocked to purchase from these companies since they don't care about the price increase? The answer is they do care and you make a very very huge assumption to believe they don't that truly defies what we witness today.
Wrong. We just talked about this. Lower production costs have been passed over to the consumer. The company likely profits more as well. Also, even if the company were to solely make profit from it, that is a US company making the profit which means more investment and tax revenue.
You again ignore the lower costs. People have a lower cost of living because of outsourcing this part of production and to go against it is fighting the market. You don't fight against the tide like an idiot and drown. You go with it and find ways to make it work to your advantage. That's what US companies have done.
That wasn't a point I was arguing and that actually is already happening. Some companies are investing in more high end machinery in the US projecting energy costs are lower. They have no reason to stay in China if they are just using machinery and the biggest factor then becomes who has the cheaper energy costs. Again, this is a free market decision that ends up tilting in our favor. You can't pick and choose the good ones.
The thing is though, like I've stated, this doesn't bring in all the jobs you're talking about. The people making these machines are already in the US.
Oh god, man. You really are becoming a stereotype of a protectionist. I say a benefit of free trade that applies to all countries and you somehow turn in into fearful restraint that has somehow been placed on us. I can't even wrap my mind around how twisted your thinking is with this reply right now so yes, you are misunderstanding me cause you seem unaware of mutual prosperity and replace it with overwhelming insecurity.
My point: Free trade benefits both nations in the respect they are less likely to engage in war because of the mutual prosperity.
Your thinking: Free trade gives leverage to other countries because we won't want to attack them and is thus a bad thing.
I'm sorry but it's completely too clear here what's going on and it's cringe worthy.
Yes it completely is. You don't understand BOTH COUNTRIES GAIN. BOTH. FUCKING BOTH DO.
This is completely your logic here.
Free Trade- BOTH country gains
No Trade- Neither country gains
"Well I don't want the other country to have gains so I think it's best we do option 2"
I'm taking this chart from the wikileaks topic because it's completely what I meant with econ 101.
Please study it. There is a guaranteed societal loss with tariffs and not engaging in free trade. China is only fucking themselves by not doing it but they have other reasons they can't which are political and actually reflect that their institutions are in many ways too weak to benefit from such a simple concept that you also cannot seem to grasp.
I don't like posting Youtube videos usually but it may help a lot.
[YT]dSQTbd2iJtY[/YT]
Also, I apologize for any of this post you may take personally. I truly am not trying to go after you or anyone in this forum personally. I can get heated at times over a discussion and do try to refrain from name calling, etc because it usually completely steers the conversation off the intended purpose. Sometimes, it does leak though and I assure you, the anger in any of these posts right now is an anger for Trump and not yourself. I wish you well and appreciate this discussion.