- Joined
- Jun 13, 2005
- Messages
- 61,692
- Reaction score
- 25,914
Breakdown of Accelerade vs. R4:
Maltodextrin/Dextrose vs. Sucrose: the former is better, but it won't make a massive difference.
Advantage: R4
WPC vs. WPC: basic protein. Same ratios.
Advantage: neither
Glutamine vs. nothing: The only time glutamine is really useful is when you're losing weight. I still take it since it's cheap, and the best time to take it is PWO when glutamine is most depleted in the muscles.
Advantage: R4.
Lecithin vs. Lecithin: the phosphadylcholine in Lecithin is a neurotransmitter which "primes" the CNS, so it's only useful pre-workout or during workout. Hence the reason I like to take these drinks then, and a separate protein shake after workouts.
Advantage: neither.
Vitamin C&E vs. Vitamin C&E: apparently it's useful to take these during workouts because (being the most effective antioxidants) their protection against free radical damage allows the athlete to produce more reps or last longer on cardio. Kleiner wrote about that.
BCAA's vs. BCAA's: I read a study that showed a solid 4% improvement in performance among elite cyclists. Apparently it achieves this through increased "focus", so the only time it was shown to be useful
was during the workout.
Advantage: neither.
Ciwujiwa vs. nothing: a hyped herb that didn't pan out. You're paying for nothing.
Advantage: Accelerade.
So you see how similar the formulas are. And at DPS similar sized canisters of R4 and Accelerade are $26 and $20 (I swear the R4 was $40 just two months ago, the last time there was a thread on this). But the formulas are best suited to take before or during a workout.
My recommendation is you make the decision based on price and taste- since the difference in the formulas is nominal.
Accelerade tastes pretty terrible. How's the R4?
Maltodextrin/Dextrose vs. Sucrose: the former is better, but it won't make a massive difference.
Advantage: R4
WPC vs. WPC: basic protein. Same ratios.
Advantage: neither
Glutamine vs. nothing: The only time glutamine is really useful is when you're losing weight. I still take it since it's cheap, and the best time to take it is PWO when glutamine is most depleted in the muscles.
Advantage: R4.
Lecithin vs. Lecithin: the phosphadylcholine in Lecithin is a neurotransmitter which "primes" the CNS, so it's only useful pre-workout or during workout. Hence the reason I like to take these drinks then, and a separate protein shake after workouts.
Advantage: neither.
Vitamin C&E vs. Vitamin C&E: apparently it's useful to take these during workouts because (being the most effective antioxidants) their protection against free radical damage allows the athlete to produce more reps or last longer on cardio. Kleiner wrote about that.
BCAA's vs. BCAA's: I read a study that showed a solid 4% improvement in performance among elite cyclists. Apparently it achieves this through increased "focus", so the only time it was shown to be useful
was during the workout.
Advantage: neither.
Ciwujiwa vs. nothing: a hyped herb that didn't pan out. You're paying for nothing.
Advantage: Accelerade.
So you see how similar the formulas are. And at DPS similar sized canisters of R4 and Accelerade are $26 and $20 (I swear the R4 was $40 just two months ago, the last time there was a thread on this). But the formulas are best suited to take before or during a workout.
My recommendation is you make the decision based on price and taste- since the difference in the formulas is nominal.
Accelerade tastes pretty terrible. How's the R4?