- Joined
- Jun 13, 2005
- Messages
- 65,403
- Reaction score
- 35,311
I think that external amplifier "Breakout Box" with all the inputs is a more attractive product than the discrete sound card.
Hardware Canucks has been putting out a lot of shill videos the past few years, and this is one. I don't care for their channel. It's become sponsored content masquerading as tech review.
Frankly, the EMI "power line noise corruption" sounds like Creative's attempt to reintroduce an old sales pitch that turned out to be hot air (as a practical concern) in the recent past, and justify it on the rationale the new RTX cards are the culprit. He says he could hear the mouse cursor while using onboard audio, but he doesn't provide a sound recording of this? Wow. I'm calling bullshit. I don't even find this credible with the dirt cheapest motherboards and PSUs on the market today, and obviously those aren't part of his setup (with the Taichi).
The high-end motherboards build in shielding to prevent power emissions from corrupting the signals of nearby lanes, and more stable power also contributes to less noise distortion. Notice the chart he supplies is a dBV chart comparing a GTX 1060 (1.0930V) to an RTX 2080 (1.0500V)? Even if the perceivable sound pressure distortion is greater relative to a 1V baseline the RTX 2080 is operating at a lower voltage level, and of course these GPUs also operate on entirely different levels of power draw. It's such a dishonest comparison, and I don't think that's a mistake. Also, why didn't he boost the dBa level while the RTX 2070 was in and edit the video to compare that to when it was boosted with the RTX 2080 Ti in? Doesn't stop there. Later, when he demonstrates the noise with the dBa bump using the dynamic vs. condenser microphones, do you notice he doesn't juxtapose onboard audio vs. the Creative sound card with the condenser mic? Thanks, Hardwarecanucks! You just did a splendid job of showing me why I should pay more for a condenser mic if I'm a streamer. You didn't show me a damn thing about onboard vs. discrete audio.
What garbage.
Besides, if one owns an RTX 2080 or 2080 Ti, and notices a level of white noise that is bothering him, the best solution is the road already traveled when the sound card makers pushed this fear years ago: to take the sound card outside the case. That's why external DAC+Amp combos blew up in the audiophile community.