Movies Edge of Tomorrow vs Groundhog Day

[The Good The Bad The HBK]

Tom relives the same day over every time he dies, Bill relives the same day over every time he wakes up. Which film is your favourite?

For me i like Bill and I like comedies, but Tom and action movies are tough to beat especially this one. Wasn't the biggest fan of the ending to Groundhog's day either.

 

[Jack Reacheround]

I loved Groundhog Day when it was first released. But it was on HBO non fucking stop from then until like 2010. So I think I got burned out on it.

Edge of Tomorrow is a movie I have seen a bunch of times but still thoroughly enjoy.

 

[Pliny Pete]

I like Edge Of Tomorrow, even though theres a huge plothole that ruins the kayfabe, its a fun explosion filled action sci fi adventure but Groundhog Day is a frickin masterpiece of pure heartwarming Americana, its got that polite, aw shucks Midwest charm and so many great little characters and funny moments, plus it has a pure evil heel that goes through a reckoning to gain redemption, its a classic comfort movie in every sense

 

[Osculater]

I never saw Groundhog Day

 

[mb23100]

Both awesome but Groundhog day. Watched Groundhog Day recently and it is a GREAT movie.

 

[Fedorgasm]

In groundhog day there is some higher power that's guiding Bill Murray to become a better person.

But in edge of if tomorrow it's just a giant worm with time travel powers or something. That kinda turned me off.

 

[The Good The Bad The HBK]

even though theres a huge plothole that ruins the kayfabe

What

 

[Spam On Rye]

Groundhog's Day is better and a bonafide classic imo. Edge of Tomorrow is one of the last solid sci fi action films I've seen as well and Cruise always delivers. Wouldn't be pissed if I had to watch either tbh.

 

[RoseHDCovington]

I loved Groundhog Day when it was first released. But it was on HBO non fucking stop from then until like 2010. So I think I got burned out on it.

Edge of Tomorrow is a movie I have seen a bunch of times but still thoroughly enjoy.

That sounds like a "you" problem

 

[Jack Reacheround]

That sounds like a "you" problem

Edge of Tomorrow is the better movie.

 

[RoseHDCovington]

I never saw Groundhog Day

Do yourself a favor, it's one of the last true classics. They do NOT make movies like this anymore.

 

[RoseHDCovington]

Edge of Tomorrow is the better movie.

Never saw it, but that's more of a "me" problem. If I'm being honest

 

[Osculater]

Do yourself a favor, it's one of the last true classics. They do NOT make movies like this anymore.

I'll check it out

 

[deviake]

Edge of Tomorrow easily.





...Not sure if I ever saw Groundhog Day.

 

[RoseHDCovington]

I'll check it out

i quote this movie. It's been a metaphor for my life. Bill Murray's comedic peak

 

[Cherry Brigand]

edge of tomorrow is SO good.

 

[Zer]

I like Bill Murray, but honestly was never that fond of Groundhog Day even though I gave it a couple of tries

Edge of Tomorrow I have only seen once but I thought it was great, so that gets the nod here

 

[Natural Order]

Edge of Tomorrow is great but isnt in the same league as Groundhog Day imo.

 

[MLarson]

Groundhog day

 

[Goon Dog]

Groundhog Day is the better movie. Edge of Tomorrow has a better collection of scenes that I'll skip to.