Great read, thanks Gono!
I already knew some parts of this controversy, but I had never seen it compiled in such a way; you made a commendable effort in dissecting each side's arguments...
Volk Han's claims about convincing Maeda to give that fight to Fedor always seemed fishy, but that was a time before everyone had a camera in their pocket, before regular folks cared about MMA, and before tweeter...
nowadays, a billingual Russian fan could immediately ask Maeda if that is true or not.
and in the span of a few hours, we could have some (for example) "lol who the fook is that guy" comment under Volk Han's interview, with a bunch of camera angles proving that he never went close to him during the fight.
Back then, realistically, who had the means to verify Volk Han's claims, and then confront him with whatever Maeda could have said in return?
That's why most of us had to rely on guys like Bas Rutten to ask someone who speaks Russian who knows a fighter from that first guy's camp who speaks Japanese, etc...
And we also had to take whatever a fighter would claim in their book for gospel...
Thanks for helping clarify muddy situations like this
GONO