- Joined
- Jun 3, 2009
- Messages
- 86,735
- Reaction score
- 26,213
Update: June 6, 2019
Dragonlord’s Review of DARK PHOENIX (No Spoilers)
Bottom Line: An unnecessary rehash with slightly better results this time around, Dark Phoenix marks the end of Fox's era of mishandling the franchise and the promise of better things to come with Marvel Studios.
Throughout the years we’ve had some really good X-Men films (X2, First Class, Days of Future Past), some decent (X-Men) and some widely-regarded really bad ones (The Last Stand, Apocalypse). Sadly, Dark Phoenix belongs to the third kind.
Longtime X-Men writer and producer Simon Kinberg makes his directorial debut and retells The Dark Phoenix Saga (he also co-wrote The Last Stand) but still fails miserably to adapt one of the most beloved X-Men comic book storylines ever. There are some slight improvements on Kinberg’s second attempt like a more nuanced characterization and downfall of Jean Grey but botches it up with haphazardly introducing an extra-terrestrial element that is just poorly executed.
The film is set in 1992 and starts off with an exciting space rescue mission with the X-Men now regarded as heroes in the eyes of the public. It’s a nice change of pace seeing the X-Men being cheered and idolized instead of being hated and hunted. The rescue mission goes awry and Jean Grey takes a hit but survives. This incident inadvertently causes Jean’s powers to spike off the charts but also unlocks a long-lost memory that starts her dark descent.
Regarded by many in the public as one of the worst actresses in Game of Thrones, I thought Sophie Turner did a respectable performance as Jean. Unlike Famke Janssen’s version in The Last Stand where her Jean just basically turns into a cold-hearted monster abruptly, Sophie’s transformation is more layered as we are privy into her emotional state filled with confusion, pain and rage.
At one point Jean visits Magneto (Michael Fassbender) in a tiny island where mutant refugees live. For comic book fans, this is just sad as this island is supposed to be Genosha. Jean’s arrival is just a contrived reason for Magneto to get involved again in the story which is a crucial problem with the recent X-Men movies as the other supposedly major characters are sidelined so that Prof. X, Magneto and Mystique get more screen time. Nonetheless, Fassbender is once again terrific as the Master of Magnetism and one of the high points of the film.
One thing that works against the film is that aside from Prof. X and Magneto, nobody really cares about the other characters. There isn't any emotional investment involved because these characters are mainly misused and marginalized for the past four X-films.
Another critical mistake by Fox is allowing each X-movies to jump to decades with each movie as if there’s a rush to catch up to 2000’s X-Men instead of taking their time after First Class and just set the next story just a few years apart. What’s worse is they squandered the reboot storyline after the events of Days of Future Past. So now we have this weird situation where characters who look way too young for their given age.
Chris Claremont's The Dark Phoenix Saga storyline was epic in its scope and Shakespearean in its tragedy. Kinberg's version is just sad with generic aliens acting as pseudo substitute for the Hellfire Club and Shi'ar Empire.
Other quick points: Cyclops was once again underused and underdeveloped (sigh). Quicksilver was sidelined early on to neutralize his OP super speed powers. Nightcrawler had some cool moments but did something out of character at the end that will leave a bad taste in your mouth if you are a Kurt Wagner comic fan. Jessica Chastain is wasted as the bland alien baddie who wants the Phoenix power for herself and her people. On one hand the action-packed finale set in a moving train was pretty good. On the other hand, there was no build-up and it just involved generic drone alien armies. The dialogue especially at the end was just horrible and corny.
Throughout the entire movie, the score was surprisingly good. Even when the scene playing was just mediocre, the fantastic music elevated it. I didn’t know until the end credits that uber composer Hans Zimmer did the soundtrack. It is no wonder that the score is one of the few highlights in the film.
And so Fox’s 19 years of handling the X-Men universe comes to an end, not with a bang but with a dud… as well as relief and excitement as this ushers the once-unfathomable dream of Marvel Studios taking over the reins on the X-Men franchise and hopefully doing it the right way. But in fairness to Fox, they brought us some memorable ones like Logan, X2, Days of Future Past and First Class. So thank you, Fox... and now kindly fuck off.
RATING: 5.5/10
Dragonlord’s Review of DARK PHOENIX (No Spoilers)
Bottom Line: An unnecessary rehash with slightly better results this time around, Dark Phoenix marks the end of Fox's era of mishandling the franchise and the promise of better things to come with Marvel Studios.
Throughout the years we’ve had some really good X-Men films (X2, First Class, Days of Future Past), some decent (X-Men) and some widely-regarded really bad ones (The Last Stand, Apocalypse). Sadly, Dark Phoenix belongs to the third kind.
Longtime X-Men writer and producer Simon Kinberg makes his directorial debut and retells The Dark Phoenix Saga (he also co-wrote The Last Stand) but still fails miserably to adapt one of the most beloved X-Men comic book storylines ever. There are some slight improvements on Kinberg’s second attempt like a more nuanced characterization and downfall of Jean Grey but botches it up with haphazardly introducing an extra-terrestrial element that is just poorly executed.
The film is set in 1992 and starts off with an exciting space rescue mission with the X-Men now regarded as heroes in the eyes of the public. It’s a nice change of pace seeing the X-Men being cheered and idolized instead of being hated and hunted. The rescue mission goes awry and Jean Grey takes a hit but survives. This incident inadvertently causes Jean’s powers to spike off the charts but also unlocks a long-lost memory that starts her dark descent.
Regarded by many in the public as one of the worst actresses in Game of Thrones, I thought Sophie Turner did a respectable performance as Jean. Unlike Famke Janssen’s version in The Last Stand where her Jean just basically turns into a cold-hearted monster abruptly, Sophie’s transformation is more layered as we are privy into her emotional state filled with confusion, pain and rage.
At one point Jean visits Magneto (Michael Fassbender) in a tiny island where mutant refugees live. For comic book fans, this is just sad as this island is supposed to be Genosha. Jean’s arrival is just a contrived reason for Magneto to get involved again in the story which is a crucial problem with the recent X-Men movies as the other supposedly major characters are sidelined so that Prof. X, Magneto and Mystique get more screen time. Nonetheless, Fassbender is once again terrific as the Master of Magnetism and one of the high points of the film.
One thing that works against the film is that aside from Prof. X and Magneto, nobody really cares about the other characters. There isn't any emotional investment involved because these characters are mainly misused and marginalized for the past four X-films.
Another critical mistake by Fox is allowing each X-movies to jump to decades with each movie as if there’s a rush to catch up to 2000’s X-Men instead of taking their time after First Class and just set the next story just a few years apart. What’s worse is they squandered the reboot storyline after the events of Days of Future Past. So now we have this weird situation where characters who look way too young for their given age.
Chris Claremont's The Dark Phoenix Saga storyline was epic in its scope and Shakespearean in its tragedy. Kinberg's version is just sad with generic aliens acting as pseudo substitute for the Hellfire Club and Shi'ar Empire.
Other quick points: Cyclops was once again underused and underdeveloped (sigh). Quicksilver was sidelined early on to neutralize his OP super speed powers. Nightcrawler had some cool moments but did something out of character at the end that will leave a bad taste in your mouth if you are a Kurt Wagner comic fan. Jessica Chastain is wasted as the bland alien baddie who wants the Phoenix power for herself and her people. On one hand the action-packed finale set in a moving train was pretty good. On the other hand, there was no build-up and it just involved generic drone alien armies. The dialogue especially at the end was just horrible and corny.
Throughout the entire movie, the score was surprisingly good. Even when the scene playing was just mediocre, the fantastic music elevated it. I didn’t know until the end credits that uber composer Hans Zimmer did the soundtrack. It is no wonder that the score is one of the few highlights in the film.
And so Fox’s 19 years of handling the X-Men universe comes to an end, not with a bang but with a dud… as well as relief and excitement as this ushers the once-unfathomable dream of Marvel Studios taking over the reins on the X-Men franchise and hopefully doing it the right way. But in fairness to Fox, they brought us some memorable ones like Logan, X2, Days of Future Past and First Class. So thank you, Fox... and now kindly fuck off.
RATING: 5.5/10