Cyborg has 1 loss in almost 20 years

[andgonsil]

That's how good Amanda is

 

[Thepaintbucket]

That loss was the most important fight of her career

 

[Bork Neslar]

Honda Housey > Kat Zingano > Amanda Nunes > Cyborg.

Honda = WMMA Goat

 

[acannxr]

That's how good Amanda is

Two-thirds of Cyborg's opponents were Flyweights and Bantamweights, it's padded.

 

[Mammothman]

Indeed, Cryroid fought mostly cans in her career, Amanda went up took her belt and her status as the WMMA GOAT like a father taking a toy from his kid.

 

[RonDante]

Meanwhile Nunes has 4 finish losses, a decision loss, and should have a 2nd decision loss against Shevchenko in their rematch

I’m not a WMMA freak though so I don’t care that much

 

[markg171]

That's how good Amanda is

Think it’s more that Amanda shocked all of us, Cyborg most of all, by fighting like that against Cyborg. Nobody expected her to just firefight with her, that was supposed to be a death sentence.

And if you try and claim otherwise I’ll call you a liar. Just like anybody saying Max should’ve pointed at the octagon and wildly exchanged with Justin like he did. Both are great ideas in hindsight, but would’ve been labelled terrible at the time as it played to their strengths.

Amanda might’ve still won, but I could see it playing out much more like this most recent fight where Cyborg was actually prepared for someone to not be afraid of her like this and it becomes a longer and more gutsy fight.

 

[Captain Herb]

I think if you overlook all of her losses to mediocre fighters, maybe she could be the goat but more likely she was pretty average for most of her career and then reached her prime late in her career. No doubt she was one of the best at a certain time but goat has to look at the entire body of work. I'd say Cyborg takes it but it could be debated on strength of schedule

 

[Senzo Tanaka]

She went ham in that fight too. You can tell she's learned from it. She's now won the world title in Strikeforce, UFC, Bellator and PFL. She may have lost to Nunes but I think she's overall the GOAT.

 

[Strijfy]

steroid munchers cant be goats

 

[Big Tuppy Hole]

Meanwhile Nunes has 4 finish losses, a decision loss, and should have a 2nd decision loss against Shevchenko in their rematch

I’m not a WMMA freak though so I don’t care that much

They also didn't pump there bodies full of PEDs to the point of questioning there gender .


Cyborg has a huge asterisk next to her name. There's no female athlete with more obvious signs of PED abuse

 

[Whitestallion]

Two-thirds of Cyborg's opponents were Flyweights and Bantamweights, it's padded.

you don't gain anything on Sherdog by talking shit, we all just notice you do it a lot and think "wow his life sucks"

Cyborg = #3 Womans GOAT

also i thought she lost TBH

 

[Hdfi]

That's how good Amanda is

yes but if Amanda comes back and loses to Kayla or Pena, she's screwed. Her win/lose ratio is 3x worse than Cyborg's.

 

[TadDunbar]

It's easy when fighting undersized waitresses, school bus drivers, and lunch ladies while being on peds

 

[StonedLemur]

Meanwhile Nunes has 4 finish losses, a decision loss, and should have a 2nd decision loss against Shevchenko in their rematch

I’m not a WMMA freak though so I don’t care that much

And Zingano straight up lit her on fire after the 1st round, and I agree that Shev won that rematch sir.

 

[acannxr]

you don't gain anything on Sherdog by talking shit, we all just notice you do it a lot and think "wow his life sucks"

Yet you're doing precisely that, so does that mean your life sucks?

How exactly is it "talking shit" to suggest that someone has a padded record because 2/3 of their opponents are 1-2 weight classes below them? Especially since it's relevant to the topic of the thread.

Also, no one elected you to speak on behalf of them, so speak for yourself.

 

[FlyingDeathKick]

Think it’s more that Amanda shocked all of us, Cyborg most of all, by fighting like that against Cyborg. Nobody expected her to just firefight with her, that was supposed to be a death sentence.

And if you try and claim otherwise I’ll call you a liar. Just like anybody saying Max should’ve pointed at the octagon and wildly exchanged with Justin like he did. Both are great ideas in hindsight, but would’ve been labelled terrible at the time as it played to their strengths.

Amanda might’ve still won, but I could see it playing out much more like this most recent fight where Cyborg was actually prepared for someone to not be afraid of her like this and it becomes a longer and more gutsy fight.

Nunes had more power than Cyborg, everybody knew this, Cyborg has always had TKO power at best. She overwhelms people, doesn't take them out with 1 punch. Short fight would always favor Nunes, if it went deeper into the rds... No chance.

 

[Only Here for Attachments]

So we're retconning Cyborg as the WGOAT now? Interesting.

 

[dominion]

So both goats in their prime and one gets mollywhopped by the other.. why would there even be a debate on who's better?

 

[smalliebiggs]

Honda Housey > Kat Zingano > Amanda Nunes > Cyborg.

Honda = WMMA Goat

Cyborg > Cat > Nunes > Rousey