• Xenforo Cloud is upgrading us to version 2.3.8 on Monday February 16th, 2026 at 12:00 AM PST. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

Comic Book Discussion Thread V.16

Status
Not open for further replies.
Strange King said:
What xmen are they then smart guy?

Also may have been wrong about battle world but I don't think I am.

Wiki It is set in an alternate universe designated as Earth-807128.

Again his Xmen died but in the new comic these xmen are not claiming to be from somewhere else they are insinuating he actually never killed them. At the end of the original he sets out to be a hero. That is where this book is picking up.

Learn some reading comprehension.

I'll type it out for you word for word. Just read the comic twice.

Edit. No point in arguing cuz who knows where he's taking it. I said at the beginning I hope he doesn't change the story of that epic comic. Will see
Click to expand...

You are wrong about your interpretation of Battleworld.

Battleword is an amalgamation of many different alternate universes which Doom created as the multiverse collapsed at the Time Runs Out storyline.

Old Man Logan didn't happen in Battleworld. A part of the world of Old Man Logan (Earth-807128) was drawn out and turned into the Wastelands by God (aka Doom).

He crosses over into a the Doman of Apocalypse and runs into a completely different set of X-Men. The fact that his Emma Frost died in issue #1 and he finds himself talking to another Emma Frost alone should tell you that. There's another version of Logan right there in the room.
 
Doughbelly said:
You are wrong about your interpretation of Battleworld.

Battleword is an amalgamation of many different alternate universes which Doom created as the multiverse collapsed at the Time Runs Out storyline.

Old Man Logan didn't happen in Battleworld. A part of the world of Old Man Logan (Earth-807128) was drawn out and turned into the Wastelands by God (aka Doom).

He crosses over into a the Doman of Apocalypse and runs into a completely different set of X-Men. The fact that his Emma Frost died in issue #1 and he finds himself talking to another Emma Frost alone should tell you that. There's another version of Logan right there in the room.
Click to expand...

Makes sense. Did you see the post above yours?
 
Strange King said:
What xmen are they then smart guy?

Also may have been wrong about battle world but I don't think I am.

Wiki It is set in an alternate universe designated as Earth-807128.

Again his Xmen died but in the new comic these xmen are not claiming to be from somewhere else they are insinuating he actually never killed them. At the end of the original he sets out to be a hero. That is where this book is picking up.

Learn some reading comprehension.

I'll type it out for you word for word. Just read the comic twice.

Edit. No point in arguing cuz who knows where he's taking it. I said at the beginning I hope he doesn't change the story of that epic comic. Will see
Click to expand...

DoughBelly pretty much summed the entire thing up...


Mind you ive been following this story for about 3 years now, from Hickmans Avengers and New Avengers #1. So if you wanna know about what you don't understand than simply ask me because I have followed this for 3 years and have collected every single issue.


and the Xmen Old Man Logan met were just one variation of Xmen. If you see the Battleworld map youll notice there are many iterations of Xmen.

'92 X-men
Xtinction Agenda X-men
E is for Extinction X-Men
Age of Apocalypse X-men


instead of arguing with me take what im saying for what its worth. In OML's domain he still killed "HIS VERSION" of the Xmen. The original story is not being tampered with even one bit, at least not so far.


So the reading comprehension is a failed attempt but on your part not mine.
 
Strange King said:
Makes sense. Did you see the post above yours?
Click to expand...

Yeah, but I don't understand what you're trying to say, nor what this guru told you.

OML the character is on Battleworld now. The events of the Old Man Logan book took place before his world was amalgamated into Battleworld.
 
Doughbelly said:
Yeah, but I don't understand what you're trying to say, nor what this guru told you.

OML the character is on Battleworld now. The events of the Old Man Logan book took place before his world was amalgamated into Battleworld.
Click to expand...

Dough how are you liking this crossover so far???

There seems to be delays already which im slightly disappointed about but other than that im really enjoying OML and I liked Planet Hulk..

Ive picked up a bunch of the #1's, I wont collect all of them as they will be on Marvel Unlimited App but I bought the #1's to see what ill collect from month to month..

So far I enjoyed all the ones I bought, although Infinity Gauntlet 1 was ok but nothing special and A-Force is the same way..

I do like Inhumans Attilan Rising, Thors, Weirdworld, OML and Planet Hulk. I think after its all said and done ill be sticking with Weirdworld, OML and Planet Hulk on a monthly.. Everything else will just be read on the Unlimited App in due time.

Ill also be getting Guardians of Knowhere just because im a Bendis junkie. Hes my boy and I follow his titles.
 
This is going to be the beauty and bane of Secret Wars. Established story lines getting a total blank slate from which to tell a new tale from. For some it will be exciting. For others, it will be akin to pissing in their Wheaties.

Secret Wars and the DC version of it has turned out a plethora of quality .99 cent sales on the digital apps. I am in a reading frenzy.
 
FyrFytr998 said:
This is going to be the beauty and bane of Secret Wars. Established story lines getting a total blank slate from which to tell a new tale from. For some it will be exciting. For others, it will be akin to pissing in their Wheaties.
Click to expand...

but it doesn't seem like past events didn't happen, they still happened but after Secret Wars main title is over im curious how and what causes everything to integrate together...


The main title is awesome, I cannot deny that much. Im enjoying this event so far and I think we'll be seeing OML in the main marvel universe as a major important player.
 
Any theory or guess on what they have planned for Cyclops in this Secret Wars? He seems to be the only X-Men left with the main players on this event. There were speculations that he will be with the Inhumans. I hope he bangs Medusa and have Black Bolt bow down to the real BOSS.
 
KONG-D'SNT-TAP said:
but it doesn't seem like past events didn't happen, they still happened but after Secret Wars main title is over im curious how and what causes everything to integrate together...


The main title is awesome, I cannot deny that much. Im enjoying this event so far and I think we'll be seeing OML in the main marvel universe as a major important player.
Click to expand...

It will be interesting to see. I only wish for ONE Marvel universe. Save all that multiple earths BS for DC.
 
KONG-D'SNT-TAP said:
Dough how are you liking this crossover so far???

There seems to be delays already which im slightly disappointed about but other than that im really enjoying OML and I liked Planet Hulk..

Ive picked up a bunch of the #1's, I wont collect all of them as they will be on Marvel Unlimited App but I bought the #1's to see what ill collect from month to month..

So far I enjoyed all the ones I bought, although Infinity Gauntlet 1 was ok but nothing special and A-Force is the same way..

I do like Inhumans Attilan Rising, Thors, Weirdworld, OML and Planet Hulk. I think after its all said and done ill be sticking with Weirdworld, OML and Planet Hulk on a monthly.. Everything else will just be read on the Unlimited App in due time.

Ill also be getting Guardians of Knowhere just because im a Bendis junkie. Hes my boy and I follow his titles.
Click to expand...

Well, I think they're a lot of fun, but it's hard to care about any of the characters or to read any of the character deaths with any weight when there are dozens of versions running around.

Ultimate Thor and Beta Ray Bill as murder police who just caught a redball is my biggest disappointment so far. So played out. I did like that 616 Thor couldn't get into the cop bar.

I have Weirdworld and a couple issues I haven't read yet, but I've already forgotten the plot to a lot of them, I guess because a lot of it's still yet in the introduction phase. Attilan Rising, Future Imperfect and Squadron Sinister, I like so far.

Best standalone story so far was the Daredevil one in the second half of Secret War Journals 2. If you haven't read that, you should.
 
KONG-D'SNT-TAP said:
DoughBelly pretty much summed the entire thing up...


Mind you ive been following this story for about 3 years now, from Hickmans Avengers and New Avengers #1. So if you wanna know about what you don't understand than simply ask me because I have followed this for 3 years and have collected every single issue.


and the Xmen Old Man Logan met were just one variation of Xmen. If you see the Battleworld map youll notice there are many iterations of Xmen.

'92 X-men
Xtinction Agenda X-men
E is for Extinction X-Men
Age of Apocalypse X-men


instead of arguing with me take what im saying for what its worth. In OML's domain he still killed "HIS VERSION" of the Xmen. The original story is not being tampered with even one bit, at least not so far.


So the reading comprehension is a failed attempt but on your part not mine.
Click to expand...

So by him crossing this wall he's on battleworld?

But on battleworld domains are seperated. Wouldn't OML crossing a wall to a different domain mean his original domain was still in battleworld?
 
Doughbelly said:
Well, I think they're a lot of fun, but it's hard to care about any of the characters or to read any of the character deaths with any weight when there are dozens of versions running around.

Ultimate Thor and Beta Ray Bill as murder police who just caught a redball is my biggest disappointment so far. So played out. I did like that 616 Thor couldn't get into the cop bar.

I have Weirdworld and a couple issues I haven't read yet, but I've already forgotten the plot to a lot of them, I guess because a lot of it's still yet in the introduction phase. Attilan Rising, Future Imperfect and Squadron Sinister, I like so far.

Best standalone story so far was the Daredevil one in the second half of Secret War Journals 2. If you haven't read that, you should.
Click to expand...

I wish they would of kept punisher\Dr strange that seemed like a badass character combo
 
Strange King said:
So by him crossing this wall he's on battleworld?

But on battleworld domains are seperated. Wouldn't OML crossing a wall to a different domain mean his original domain was still in battleworld?
Click to expand...

Not his original domain in it's entirety. Just a piece of it.
 
So I'm gonna go back to The Killing Joke, but on another note

Converse released these bad boys, I don't know if any of you all collect these, they go fast though

1_337757_FS_ALT1.JPG
 
Would wear.
 
Strange King said:
So by him crossing this wall he's on battleworld?

But on battleworld domains are seperated. Wouldn't OML crossing a wall to a different domain mean his original domain was still in battleworld?
Click to expand...

No the entire thing is called Battleworld but where he lives (old man Logan universe) is just a domain on Battleworld.

And when he crosses the wall (just like what captain America is doing in planet hulk) he is just crossing domains. His domain/universe is just a small piece of Battleworld.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,282,073
Messages
58,412,266
Members
176,031
Latest member
Golden Rhino

Share this page

Back
Top