This will always be the first thing that comes to mind anytime someone mentions Cain.
"the guy who lost to jds"? I remember him as the guy who destroyed JDS career
HIs cardio level is a myth. Their are many hw who had just as good of cardio as him.
Although he had good cardio for a hw.
He was always overhyped. Zuffa sold you him as the best most well rounded fighter.
Despite fighting 8 times. They told you all how he’s unquestionably the best and you ate it.
Cain is a good hw. He’s not a top 5 hw. And that’s just the facts of a fighting career.
He had the benefit of a promotional buzzsaw pumping him up.
He beat a geriatric noguiera who couldn’t move.
He beats jds twice. And Bigfoot twice.
Never tested against various styles.
When he fought werdum. You saw how well rounded he actually is.
Werdum better stand up. Better in the clinch. Better on the ground.
And that’s a jiu jitsu guy beating him in all of those areas.
Every time he faced adversity he failed.
All of those things will tell you he’s not one of the top 5 hw in mma history.
But the main thing is his resume.
JDS resume is better no contest but after the beating he took vs cain he became a different fighterThat seems nuts considering Dos Santos would go on to be a fixture in the top 10 after losing to Cain.
Goes on to beat:
Hunt, KO
Stipe, UD
Rothwell, UD
Blagoy, UD
Tuivasa, KO
Lewis, KO
Loses to:
Overeem
Stipe (they are 1-1)
Ngannou (also murdered Cain)
If you can believe it, Cain only had three more fights after his second win over JDS, and he went 1-2, getting put away twice. There is nothing to suggest Cain could have beat all the guys JDS did. In fact if he could have, he would have.
Agree with all of that. Perhaps at best he is ‘arguably’ top 5 if you look at the short window of his prime but in terms of longevity amongst the elite you can’t put him ahead of someone like Couture let alone Fedor.
As with Cruz, the injuries and inactivity bloated his time of being considered relevant and when he returned this year he was despatched very quickly and his subsequent retirement is likely a product of now knowing he has no business being in there with guys like Ngannou. Even had he fought more regularly the losses to JDS and Werdum suggest his record would have been littered with losses.
HIs cardio level is a myth. Their are many hw who had just as good of cardio as him.
Although he had good cardio for a hw.
He was always overhyped. Zuffa sold you him as the best most well rounded fighter.
Despite fighting 8 times. They told you all how he’s unquestionably the best and you ate it.
Cain is a good hw. He’s not a top 5 hw. And that’s just the facts of a fighting career.
He had the benefit of a promotional buzzsaw pumping him up.
He beat a geriatric noguiera who couldn’t move.
He beats jds twice. And Bigfoot twice.
Never tested against various styles.
When he fought werdum. You saw how well rounded he actually is.
Werdum better stand up. Better in the clinch. Better on the ground.
And that’s a jiu jitsu guy beating him in all of those areas.
Every time he faced adversity he failed.
All of those things will tell you he’s not one of the top 5 hw in mma history.
But the main thing is his resume.
Cardio to match:HWs rarely have good cardio can you name even a handful of HWs who had cardio like Cain when he first won the title? Nogueira was 3-1 in the ufc when he fought Cain and his last 3 were against the 3 previous ufc hw champions before Lesnar so obviously he wasn’t the 2003 Nogueira but he for sure was still a top HW at that time. He beat JDS twice winning and defending the UFC title. He beat Bigfoot while they were both coming off losses and then again after Bigfoot Ko’d Travis Browne(contender at that time) and Ubereem also a contributing factor is that Bigfoot was blinded 30 seconds into the first fight by a cut and the ufc gave him a shot deservingly so. He faced plenty of adversity he was beat by JDS and came back to destroy him twice that still counts as adversity.
He did face several different style match ups. He has fought strikers, wrestlers, BJJ specialist, he had a short career but it was for the most part all in the ufc. 14-3 12-3 in the ufc. His injuries seriously derailed his career. I say all the time he is the Ken Griffey jr of mma had years of greatness and could have been the all time great but injuries fucked him over.
I honestly believe people just look at his record and don’t actually look back at history. There is context to every fighters record that’s why it’s important to go back and watch fights from the past and not get lost in fight finders.