@Ackmed
he's kind of right, tho
Some parts of his post are right (yes Islam did move from #9 to #5 after his last win against #14).
But he's wrong to imply that Islam's #5 rank is illegitimate.
If there were LWs below Islam with better recent performances and a better record then I can see his argument but that's simply not the case.
Let's see:
#6 Tony - he got dominated in 3 consecutive fights. Yeah his competition was tough but he didn't even win any rounds against them...he offered almost no resistance against them...so he shouldn't be ranked above Islam.
#7 RDA - his win over Felder was good. Felder didn't have a training camp and RDA also had a change in opponents & fighting stlyle on short notice. Is that win more impressive than Islam's recent performances? Not IMO. RDA should be above Tony though.
#8 Hooker - he's faced tougher competitors but has been a 50/50 fighter in his last 6 fights with two losses in a row...should not be ranked above Islam...should be ranked above Tony though
#9 Conor - I don't need to elaborate on this one, he shouldn't be ranked above Islam
#10 Gillespie - has good performances except a KO loss against FKL in his second last fight so he shouldn't be ranked above Islam's 8 fight win streak
Same story if we go lower in the rankings.
Unless someone can justify a revised LW ranking order that shows Islam below #5, posts complaining about his rank are baseless.