My review of this movie:
I've always been a Marvel fan since the 80's because I've always felt their characters were more personable, flawed, and human. When I think of DC, I think of Alex Ross and their superheroes as gods, and as great as an artist as he is, I just never took to this look. I frankly think it's silly but the anti-establishment of the 90's can do that to you. The MCU has portrayed their characters with the spirit of their comics which is to say, they don't struggle with coming to grips with their powers (like X-Men), but they struggle to understand their own role in life with them, and even in the larger team-ups like Avengers Assemble and Civil War, there always was an internal strife to overcome while defeating an outer one. But with this latest offering from Marvel Studios, that sense of epic scale, of mythological proportions like an Alex Ross painting which DC fans understand, comes to the theater which no comic book movie has done before. Everyone is harping on this being the 10th year anniversary but that is no hype and is the key to everything done well in Infinity War.
So the thing that really impressed upon me was just how heroic everyone felt. I guess its second nature now that everyone has had a movie of their own and with the stakes raised this high. But I was still awe-struck. Tony has been quivering over the last few movies and to see him finally with no quit going one-on-one against Thanos and then getting creamed in the process defined it for me. And then the others like Dr. Strange with supreme confidence pulling out every trick in his sleeve. Peter Parker taking a one-way trip into outer space just to help his idol. Thor visibly shook but getting back up to fight an unassailable enemy. The sacrifices which all the characters have had up to this point resonate in their respective battles, and reflects how hard they will fight to save that which is good. So to judge this movie by itself is impossible nor should it even be attempted. To plot the basic story would be like this: Avengers 1 is where the team learns to work together. Avengers 2: the team unit, with an appropriately superficial party scene, is tested. Civil War: the team breaks up. Infinity War: members die and that obviously doesn't work without what came before.
With so little screen-time given to any one character, the Russos are still able to provide the culmination if not progression of these characters' stories only by telling a very simple theme in these team-up movies: camaraderie and friendship. When Steve shows up to help Vision and Wanda, immediately there's a sense that everything is going to be okay. While Proxima Midnight and Corvus Glaive are heavyweights, I found it believable that the team is able to defeat them simply because they are the Avengers and they're veterans in functioning as a group and most importantly that they believe that too. Even with all the separate fracturing of teams, it's through their coming together that each is able to launch any defense at all. Quick scenes like Okoye and Nat defending Wanda, or Groot getting off his ass and creating the handle for Stormbreaker are just mark-out moments that exemplify how this movie is truer to that idea of fighting for each other than say Avengers Assemble where it was through necessity.
But it's not enough. Thanos as a protagonist, villain, and glue to this film works incredibly well. He's a thoughtful villain and aside from getting to one place to another, doesn't rush which is really refreshing. I hate villains who are not in control and are racing against the hero (eg. Malekith) but in true Thanos fashion, the dialogue and exposition is a part of his process. It could've been better though: Comic Thanos' speech bubbles always have a course outline suggesting an incredibly deep and villainous voice which Josh Brolin does well but not as how I would have imagined it. Also, Thanos tends to wax poetic a lot which wasn't as pronounced. And finally, I really am disappointed that Mistress Death romance angle was not included as that is both his primary motivation but his biggest weakness. But all those are nitpicks coming from a comic book fan. MCU Thanos is menacing without ever raising his voice, has a strange but not unbelievable motivation, and is extremely capable. I loved hating him in this movie and wished he went down horribly. He also gets a couple legit close calls that would've ruined him which I really enjoyed because the villain is able to overcome and makes the mistake for later that it was destiny when really it was luck.
For once, I'm glad that I have a least a semblance of where the story is going to go from here due to the comics. It makes the anticipation for Avengers 4 even greater than this one. The OG members survived the cull, Gamora is probably in the soul stone, Strange has a plan and Nebula is still in the game. Hulk will probably go ape-shit when he finally goes green and we still haven't seen a couple of iconic moments like Cap's vibranium shield getting shattered or him lifting the hammer (which likely won't happen anymore). It's crazy to think how much investment this project was and to span it over two movies. The enjoyment only works if you've followed and liked the action over the 10 years but it goes both ways: it's that much more enjoyable because of it.
Random thoughts:
Plot holes like why didn't Strange use the Time Stone or do the portal closing trick are not as bad as Zemo lure in Civil War so it didn't affect me.
What mildly does affect me is everyone's nigh indestructibility such as Wanda crashing through glass roofs and dozens of feet onto hard floor and walking away from it like nothing.
Loki dying a hero's death could really be the end of his story-line and should be revisited should it not be an illusion and he doesn't come back for any more movies.
Rocket acting as the sane voice to Thor's madness was cool.