it is knowledge she doesnt want him to know ..... its the location of the soul stoneIt's not knowledge she wants Thanos to not have. She knows something about him that would get her killed if he knew she knew. She heads straight there because they need to get the stones or everyone dies.
So it's avoid Thanos and die or go to Thanos and maybe live but most likely die.
I'm not completely sold on this theory. He may not want to come out for fear of losing control.They didnt say it in the movie, but my take is that Hulk isnt coming out because he got fucking smashed by Thanos. He got full on Holly Holmed and now he has the purple pillow in front of his face.
I am surprised you haven't seen it six or seven times by now...It was even better the 2nd time watching it
![]()
They didnt say it in the movie, but my take is that Hulk isnt coming out because he got fucking smashed by Thanos. He got full on Holly Holmed and now he has the purple pillow in front of his face.
Hulk afraid of losing control?I'm not completely sold on this theory. He may not want to come out for fear of losing control.

He may just need to be off earth and away from civilization before he can come out again. There is bound to be an enormous amount of rage built up after that beating from Thanos. I think we saw Hulk fleshed out enough in Ragnarok to believe he knows what will happen if he gets into a fight with Thanos or any bad guys on earth at the moment.This. I think he was in shock that someone actually just flat out overpowered him as he's not used to that. Yeah he got pounded a few times in the past by Thor and Tony in the Hulkbuster but maybe it didn't hurt as much as Thanos pounding the shit out of him or something. And he was never completely out in those fight but against Thanos it look like he was flat out KOed.
My prediction : Hulk will come back after he watch Black Widow dies in Avengers 4 and will go on an absolute rampage. I also think he will eventually get his rematch with Thanos.
It was even better the 2nd time watching it
![]()
I know it doesn't fit his comic personality but even at the end of the fight with stark in Ultron he looked around like he knew what he had just done.Hulk afraid of losing control?
![]()
Hulk isn't some mindless beast. In Thor Ragnarok, Hulk explicitly says that he didn't want to return to Earth because he knows that Earth hates him. This is the same Hulk that jumps on Surtur without a second thought because he sees a big monster. The "Holly Holm" analogy is entertaining, but doesn't make complete sense. Especially when you consider the previous movie that Hulk is actually in (in a fully coherent, speaking role on top of that).Hulk afraid of losing control?
![]()
The thing about this explanation is it kinda shits on thor ragnarok. He was clearly in control of hulk the whole movie and all of a sudden cant transform to him? Not only that but he could have just put himself in harms way and had to transform like in the last 3 movies. It was kinda a weak non excuse for them to not use him so he wasnt over powering everyone.This. I think he was in shock that someone actually just flat out overpowered him as he's not used to that. Yeah he got pounded a few times in the past by Thor and Tony in the Hulkbuster but maybe it didn't hurt as much as Thanos pounding the shit out of him or something. And he was never completely out in those fight but against Thanos it look like he was flat out KOed.
My prediction : Hulk will come back after he watch Black Widow dies in Avengers 4 and will go on an absolute rampage. I also think he will eventually get his rematch with Thanos.
This must be how it felt to get punched by Thanos...
He does walk offscreen when the Hulk attacks and then reappeara before dying ignobly.
I wouldn't be shocked if he was dead but treachery is his schtick, after all.

The thing about this explanation is it kinda shits on thor ragnarok. He was clearly in control of hulk the whole movie and all of a sudden cant transform to him? Not only that but he could have just put himself in harms way and had to transform like in the last 3 movies. It was kinda a weak non excuse for them to not use him so he wasnt over powering everyone.
Theory time:
How do you guys think Nebula and Tony get off of Titan? My only guess is Thor uses the bi-frost or some how Nebula's ship she used to crash into Dad is still functioning.
I agree...completely. Had this been a stand alone/none canon movie, this would have been one of the greatest comic book movies of all time. I was just waiting for the moment someone from the Avengers team suddenly swaps in cracking jokes and somehow stopping Thanos from getting the stone and ending the movie on that note-Thanos fails but tries again the second one. Feigie and whoever oversaw the production of this movie deserves a fucking pay raise. Quips aside, there's really not much to complain about in this movie. It really feels like they let the Russo bros do their thing with this.I mean we all know there is a part 2, but the Russos were right when they said this could be a standalone movie.
This was Thanos' movie. The movie ends with him accomplishing his goal. The bad guy won this time
Roll credits.