Movies AVENGERS: INFINITY WAR Thread v.9

Status
Not open for further replies.
Respectfully, the stones being stronger when they're combined is something i understood without ever having read a comic on the subject. I'd go so far as to say that it was obvious.

Also, if the time stone can take you back in time... then what's the problem with wielding that one stone & going back & letting Focus & witch know what's about to happen... get him to Wakanda & extract the stone & destroy it before any of this happens? It really does seem to be a major gap in the story.

don't get me wrong... I'm able to enjoy the film & overlook stuff like that... but if we're discussing whether or not the time stone alone is all that's needed then we gotta get real about someone having the ability to take their current knowledge back in time to re-invent the past. Strange knew the Witch could destroy a stone. so go back & destroy one. easy.
when has Dr Strange ever met Scarlet Witch in the MCU? or Vision*? he'd only ever interacted with Thor in the MCU before this movie

travelling through time with the time stone has already been shown to be too dangerous, as it creates paradoxes with unknown consequences. Its not as simple as you are making out.
 
AVENGERS 4: THE DEATH OF CAPTAIN AMERICA

tenor.gif
 
someone started calling Thanos "Rick" because they say he looks like some idiot on a tv show(he doesnt)

and "Ben" is for Benedict Cumberbatch lol....... although the guy with the Papa Doc reference for Falcon was pretty funny lol
thanos only looks like rich piana imo.
 
when has Dr Strange ever met Scarlet Witch in the MCU? or Vision*? he'd only ever interacted with Thor in the MCU before this movie

travelling through time with the time stone has already been shown to be too dangerous, as it creates paradoxes with unknown consequences. Its not as simple as you are making out.

Actually if Strange has seen the one path that leads to victory then that means he witness everything that happened after he vanished as well. That means he knew that Thanos got all the stones hence he saw how Scarlet Witch destroyed the stone.

But agreed it's way more difficult than that. Even with the suggested scenario Thanos has 4 gems and can easily catch up to Strange and take his stone eventually. The wildcard that allows Thanos to retrieve the remaining stones is the reality stone.

Reality Stone ability - Allows the user to fulfill their wishes, even if the wish is in direct contradiction with scientific laws, and do things that would normally be impossible; and create any type of alternate reality the user wishes.

This stone would allow Thanos to break Strange's spell and take the time stone. With the time stone he can time travel and retrieve the last stone. Honestly as soon as he snagged the reality stone it was over. Any scenario can be undone or redone to Thanos's liking. With the power and space stone it makes him impossible to stop. Actually he could have used the soul stone to control Strange too..

There was no stopping Thanos in any possible scenario once he got 3 stones IMO.
 
Fuckin' asshole? You're the one who stuck his nose in a response to an idiotic suggestion.

here's what happened:

1. equus suggested that marvel will milk this by making 2 more movies before capping it with the infinity finale.

2. I told him that's no logistically possible. since you insist on more details here is why:
a. old guard actors are not on contract
b. 2nd part of Infinity War is already shot and being finished for a 2019 release date

For equus scenario to happen Marvel would have to pull Infinity War part 2 (which would piss off every fuckin fan out there), re-sign some/all of the actors, hire new ones and build additional storylines for these 2 new movies and then produce them. that's going to take AT LEAST 2-3 years for the first one (conservatively speakin'). they would also have to adjust every other MCU movie to accommodate for this change so every other MCU characters will be stuck in another infinity war arc for the next 4-5 years. If they're pulling from Infinity War (comic book) and/or Infinity Crusade story that's a shit ton of new material that would force them to fix the 2nd movie of Infinity War for sure. I doubt they will do that. The logistics from a storytelling POV would be so complex no one in their right mind would want to do this. Not only that but delaying the finale of Infinity War for at least 4-5 years would be stupid.

It's logistically impossible but if you disagree I am willing to bet money it won't happen. whatever odds you are want.

3. your suggested scenario of thanos losing his glove cause he stashed it somewhere and someone else swiped it is so asinine from a storytelling POV. It would enrage and insult fans "WHY DA FUCK DID THANOS LOSE IT SO EASILY!!!". We're not talking DC storytelling retardation here. Kevin Feige, the Russo brothers and everyone involved in building the MCU painstakingly work to ensure the material is respected. No marvel fan would be happy with something as stupid as Thanos losing his infinity gauntlet in this manner...

equus was making a joke
 
so i have to read this entire thread and the last comic discussion thread....itll take me a while as im extremely busy these days...anyway...im sure this is bitched about in here...somewhere....

i HATE seperation of xmen and marvel universes. the possibilities of the outcomes in regards to past comics is insane. i know we dont exactly get the comics like they are remembered. but i was going over old infinity stuff and remember how much i loved all the characters involvements. sonny and i just talked about this the other day... fantastic four sucks...all the incarnations of it suck but holy shit...they were integral in their involvement. silver surfer was better. he was the hulk in the stranges mansion scene in the comic. ADAM FUCKING WARLOCK wasnt an end credits easter egg. wolverine and cyclops were there....shehulk existed...man...im nerding out.

and i have always hated how singer just picked and chose different xmen heroes and villains from different eras. what a convoluted mess...ok im done for the moment.
It kind of pisses me off that they didn't play nice with each other. I can't see why the companies can't just take a lesser percentage on a couple of crossovers without Disney having to absorb everything.

Aside from that, I don't mind the cinematic deviations from the core mythologies, and I'm quite willing to forgive mistakes in execution in a film that's trying to do something different, rather than a film that plays it safe but still suffers from a few shortcomings.

INFINITY GAUNTLET pretty much hit at the height of my comic book collecting days. I'd already been one of the three people reading SILVER SURFER (which, I believe, was the third incarnation of the series, and the longest one) and witnessed the auspicious beginning of Ron Lim. Then Jim Starlin, whom I wasn't familiar with at the time, took over writing duties. While the series was always cosmically-oriented, even then I could tell Jim Starlin was taking it in a serious direction. Thanos was rebooted in the popular-at-the-time anti-hero mold, and it was hard not to like him. For my money, THANOS QUEST > INFINITY GAUNTLET. Still, it's neat the film managed to capture the same emotional progression where you end up being on his side just as much as you're not. I prefer that the film shifts the focus onto Gamora, which makes Thanos ten times more likeable and timeless. His obsession with Death feels so dated, to the 90s as well as Starlin's acid trip years previous.
 
It kind of pisses me off that they didn't play nice with each other. I can't see why the companies can't just take a lesser percentage on a couple of crossovers without Disney having to absorb everything.

Aside from that, I don't mind the cinematic deviations from the core mythologies, and I'm quite willing to forgive mistakes in execution in a film that's trying to do something different, rather than a film that plays it safe but still suffers from a few shortcomings.

INFINITY GAUNTLET pretty much hit at the height of my comic book collecting days. I'd already been one of the three people reading SILVER SURFER (which, I believe, was the third incarnation of the series, and the longest one) and witnessed the auspicious beginning of Ron Lim. Then Jim Starlin, whom I wasn't familiar with at the time, took over writing duties. While the series was always cosmically-oriented, even then I could tell Jim Starlin was taking it in a serious direction. Thanos was rebooted in the popular-at-the-time anti-hero mold, and it was hard not to like him. For my money, THANOS QUEST > INFINITY GAUNTLET. Still, it's neat the film managed to capture the same emotional progression where you end up being on his side just as much as you're not. I prefer that the film shifts the focus onto Gamora, which makes Thanos ten times more likeable and timeless. His obsession with Death feels so dated, to the 90s as well as Starlin's acid trip years previous.

i cant disagree at all. and i absolutely loved the Infinity 6 part with Thanos a few years ago.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top