Aldo vs BJ Penn

[UL]

<DrakeLaugh>
Prime BJ's boxing is one of the most overrated thing in MMA history.

BJ is just straight up overrated
yes a good fighter at that time
but don't act like he was some goat and can knock a bloody elephant out

 

[lostdog000]

prime aldo over prime bj
but the difference might be roids

 

[tdluxon]

Aldo

As much as I love bj, I think Aldo takes him out hard. I'd love to watch though

 

[Sjb1888]

Aldo, convincingly.

 

[Agent Mulder's Hair]

Aldo's leg kicks might be a problem. Never seen BJ have to deal with that in his prime. But probably BJ beats the shit out of him.

 

[jk7707]

Aldo. I still cringe thinking about that fight with Faber.

 

[Agent Mulder's Hair]

Also is really Penn 2.0, they're evenly matched in the grappling department but Aldo is quicker and has kicks and knees. Penn is slow and could be countered. I would love to watch it and would pick Aldo.

BJ had knees too. He knocked out Din Thomas with one and Sean Sherk with one.

And BJ wasn't really slow. He conserved energy in there, and it kinda made him look a little slow at times. But really he was picking his spots and shots. And his timing was really good.

 

[tdluxon]

Lol @ prime BJ

Prime BJ got beat by Edgar
Prime BJ wouldn't last against many of the current LW fighters right now


Aldo via whatever he wants

This is a good point. Mma math doesn't necessarily work out, but Frankie , the guy who knocked bj off and took him again in the rematch, really had nothing for Aldo, who took him to school hard.

 

[FinBJJ]

Aldo would be the favorite in my eyes, but with BJ's power he would have a slim chance to knock him out.

 

[tru3f4n]

Prime BJ would touch him with teh jab.

Prime BJ would have a fight IQ of a Prime Lawler and would be limping around the cage by rnd 2 gassed by rnd 3 and carried out on his back before it went the distance.

 

[Bjjpitbull8]

Oh boy, I might have just triggered BJ penn worshiper.

Again, BJ's boxing was hyped to the gill by UFC and the fans at that time.

LOL. Yes my response just screams worship. Says the guy who has now attacked my post twice to show his saltiness toward Penn's greatness.

Look it's your insides.

 

[Agent Mulder's Hair]

BJ is just straight up overrated
yes a good fighter at that time
but don't act like he was some goat and can knock a bloody elephant out

He might not could knock an elephant out but he certainly could knock Aldo out.

 

[Agent Mulder's Hair]

This is a good point. Mma math doesn't necessarily work out, but Frankie , the guy who knocked bj off and took him again in the rematch, really had nothing for Aldo, who took him to school hard.

BJ won that first Frankie fight.

 

[YellowBaneno]

LOL. Yes my response just screams worship. Says the guy who has now attacked my post twice to show his saltiness toward Penn's greatness.

Look it's your insides.

You sound defensive and angry.

Did I hurt your feeling honey ? All i did was simply replying to your post, don't be so dramatic.

BJ penn was a limited fighter. His boxing looked good in comparison to the awful striking of his opponents he faced at that time. He literally had no kicking game. His bjj is the only thing that i consider it to be on top level.

 

[tdluxon]

BJ won that first Frankie fight.

I wanted him to. Close fight, I could see it going either way

 

[Toner]

Aldo beats any version of any fighter in MMA history if they were all the same size.

 

[dildos]

prime BJ is a myth most overrated fighter of all times

you are a can.

 

[Agent Mulder's Hair]

I wanted him to. Close fight, I could see it going either way

It was close. A lot closer than Aldo/Frankie. And it's been years since I watched it so I could be wrong, but I remember thinking BJ got robbed. But I'm an unashamed BJ nuthugger so I could be biased.

 

[Bjjpitbull8]

You sounds defensive and angry.

Did I hurt your feeling honey ? All i did was simply replying to your post, don't be so dramatic.

BJ penn was a limited fighter. His boxing looked good in comparison to the awful striking of his opponents he faced at that time. He literally had no kicking game. His bjj is the only thing that i consider it to be top level.

He never needed it. It's sort of hard to kick when you're knocked the fuck out with your head split open and BJ is licking your blood off his gloves.

But but but BJ has no kick game. Fuck outta here. What happened in life that made you such an angry misinformed hater? I feel bad for you buddy. And your grammar is awful. Stop skipping school.

 

[Oooxente]

Hard fight to call
Prime BJ and Aldo have fighting styles very similar despite the difference in choice for striking .
UD for whoever win.

Humm
Now if we put angry WEC Aldo i give the advantage to Aldo.