- Joined
- May 14, 2004
- Messages
- 11,337
- Reaction score
- 10,337
Although really I think the problem is that simply scaring the audience just isnt that hard, a few simple tricks that modern horror just endlessly recycles but creating an interesting story around that or indeed creating more of a doom ladden atmosphere is a lot harder.
The problem with modern horror I tend to think is that it became limited in its audience to "horror fans" who really just want to see those tricks done a million times, the same jumpscares recycled by not very talented directors. Horror in the 70's and 80's though that was an era were directors like Kubrick, Scott, Parker, etc made horror films.
Honestly I always thought that Scream was the begining of the end personally, its not a terrible film in itself but it paved the way for endlessly teen jumpscare horror to follow.
I actually wanted to make a thread about my feelings towards modern horror but I'll share some of my thoughts here.
In my opinion, modern horror suffers and benefits from the trend of atmospheric horror. I know you alluded to the fact that modern horror is just rife with formulaic jump scares by talentless hacks. But truth be told, it's atmospheric horror that modern horror is known for. Im talking the past 10 years or so. Now although I do agree that atmospheric horror is MUCH harder to pull off than jump scares, it suffers from being tremendously boring.
The babadook really illustrates this perfectly. It was exceptionally boring and although the director did a good job of creating that creepy aura, it just wasn't scary and left a lot to be desired. After that film it became this cock measuring contest between horror film directors of who could do the least with regards to tension build up and rely solely on atmosphere alone. It became pretentious, which brings me to my next point.
All of these movies are always a metaphor for something and its just tiring at this point. The babadook - depression, Annihilation - self destruction, Midsommar - gaslighting, suspiria - trauma, It follows - mortality (not stds), nighthouse - emptiness etc etc.
Like can we just go back to making movies with the intention of scaring people? I don't want a life lesson or some deep, artistic interpretation into post partum depression or what ever the fuck else.
Also because of these factors, horror movies end up being just good movies rather than good HORROR movies. Like last night in soho. Wonderful flick, horrible horror movie. The production values are so high and the directors are so motivated by the metaphorical, artsy fartsy bull shit that they tend to forget about the scary shit and just end up producing a good flick.
Im going to say it........we need to get back to jump scares. We did the atmospheric thing and it was cool but it's boring as fuck and it isn't scary.
Last edited: