49-46? No way!

[memoriesofrem]

48-47 Aldo. Frankie had his chance but didn't do enough to take the third round away from that face kick.

 

[rac2]

Stop listening to Joe Rogan.

this.

this fight was a clear 49-46.

 

[TheComebackKid]

Aldo won the 5th and the 3rd could go either way

 

[Papasmurf45619]

Edgar won 4 and 5. 3 was close, but I'd give the nod to Aldo

48-47 Aldo's toughest fight yet

 

[Sumbog]

I had Aldo winning 1-2-3-5

 

[Archleone]

Stop listening to Joe Rogan.

 

[jban]

Next times watch the fights without listening to Rogan. Fight was 49-46. End of story. End of thread.

 

[SPL1FF]

awesome fight.

the 125 and 145 division saved the card.

 

[axecutioner]

5 went to Aldo. They landed about equal. It's possible Edgar got a little more in, but Aldo was hurting him much more.

 

[reapfate]

Id say he took the last 2 with the takedown in the 4th and he stayed more active in the 5th but yeah I would have still said 48-47 Aldo

 

[HungryHippo]

This judging is outta control!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 4 & 5 were Edgar.






Maybe it's the angle they're viewing from? Get them some TV monitors.

I seriously think Aldo won round 5, edgar was more active but he wasn't landing effectively.

 

[Nomad Nemesis**]

damage is the #1 criteria.

if joe rogan riding your nuts was #1, then frankie would have won

i see frankie going to 135

 

[Nate1492]

I too had had Edgar winning 3, 4 and 5

How much money/pride did you lose on this fight?

There is no way Frankie 'won' round 3. At *best* 10-10 round 3, but did you forget about the near knockout front kick? It was a 5 minute round where Edgar looked better for 2 minutes, and there was a near knockout.

Round 5 was very close.

My score was 49-47:
10-9
10-9
10-9
9-10
10-10

But almost no judge does 10-10s, so if you *forced* me to pick a winner, I'd have picked Aldo for ending it with the Superman.

 

[TASTEofmySCYTHE]

It was pretty close I gave Aldo 1-2, Edgar 4-5, and the 3rd was a toss-up.

I expected Aldo to get the decision, but I don't think it's ridiculous to say Frankie could have won either.

 

[Ughugh]

I had 4 and 5 Frankie with 3 going either way. You'd might as well toss a coin at that point so it's only fair the fighter who did the most damage won.

49-46 is a bit overzealous though.

 

[VAfan]

i had it the same as rogan, 3-2 aldo.

 

[Cazador]

Rogan's comments stopped having an effect on how I score a round a while ago so no, I don't think 49-46 was that off.

 

[Hallzzz]

I thought Aldo won

1,2, and 5 easily

 

[forzaitalia]

1 - Aldo DOMINANCE
2 - Aldo DOMINANCE
3 - Could go either way
4 - Frankie convincingly
5 - Good fight by Frankie, but clearly Aldo

Aldo did not win round 5.

this was a very close fight. 1 and 2 Aldo, 4 and 5 Edgar. The third is up for debate I suppose. neither really stood out in that round, so i dont know.

But i still lol at the people that said Aldo would merc Edgar. Nonetheless I will enjoy the debate as to who won.

 

[FlyingSpladle]

fuck 49-46, I can see 48-47 for Aldo or Edgar. That's it.