Top 3 GOAT is pretty clear at this point right?

[Shaddows]

Seems pretty clear its

#1 GSP
#2 Fedor
#3 DJ

or #2 DJ and #3 Fedor, I wont argue. We all agree on this right?

Fedor
DJ
Silva

Jon Jones as honorable mention.

 

[jaredmc16]

Steroids aside:

1. Fedor
2. Jones
3. GSP
4. Anderson
5. Nog

 

[Deleted member 501827]

GSP
Fedor
Anderson

I remember that being everyones concensus back in 2009. A lots changed especially for Anderson since then.

 

[BoD 2.0]

1. GSP
2. Jones
3. Anderson
4. Fedor
5. Aldo

 

[SomniumRabidum]

1. Fedor
2. GSP
3. Jones

Silva, DJ, Aldo, in some order...

 

[NoContest]

Out of GSP, Fedor, Anderson and Jones, you have the top 3.

 

[canadian_mmafan]

Miocic is just greatest UFC heavyweight of all time at this point. Too soon to put him in any GOAT conversations. I dont see how anyone can not have GSP in their top 3. Unless yours is not a P4P GOAT list.

i dont believe in p4p. p4p is deceitful, compensating for an handicap. p4p means all things being equal basically, u cant translate that. all things being equal lets say a wheelchair basketballer is better than jordan??? or is he. NOPE. I dont give much credence to the lower weight divisions. if I like a light heavyweight and feel hes great, ill give him credit but ill always wonder why he feared fighting at his natural weight against a heavyweight

 

[Fatal Catro]

No, we don't.

Only Conor/Ronda noobs would consider the mouse a goat.

Explain this , what's the connection to Conor and Ronda ?.

 

[Deleted member 501827]

Even if you put steroids aside and all his terrible losses, Anderson is still too incomplete of a fighter to be ranked in the top 3 or even 5 really. His wrestling is terrible. Hes like the one guy in the conversation of greats by some with a massive hole in his game.

 

[King Joffery]

This will not be a popular answer ...but it is the correct one.

don't be a clown.. conor has lost 2 out of his last 4..lost to nate fucking diaz and conor was in his prime... lost that second diaz fight too

Lost the 2nd fight lol, now who is clowning, I know you don't really believe that. Also in first fight he had a Staph infection so hardly in his prime but Conor doesn't like to make excuses so didn't even bring it up.

 

[Kumason]

A Goat discussion on Sherdog?Never heard one before,i'm baffled and amazed.

 

[Nimrod]

Fedor
Anderson S
Royce Gracie

 

[Fight Professor]

GSP
Conor
Aldo

 

[Squall10]

Fedor
Anderson
Nog

 

[Perrichet]

GSP
Fedor
MM

 

[ThunderStruck]

http://forums.sherdog.com/threads/your-fighter´s-goat.3730621/


Thought some might like a count as opposed to the jumbled mess.

Fedor: 37
Silva: 36
Jones: 29
GSP: 16

WAsn't that before Silva popping for roids, Jones popping a second time, Fedor getting KO'd multiple times and GSP winning the MW strap? I think so.

 

[jaredmc16]

Fedor
Anderson
Nog

Everyone always forgets about nog... but he was 32-4 at one point with two of those losses being split decisions which he avenged, and the other two vs Fedor.

Had never been finished and probably fought the toughest schedule of fighters of all time

 

[ThunderStruck]

Ignoring positive tests for PEDs (else DJ would be 3rd).

1. GSP
2. Fedor
3. Jones

 

[Dozer .]

WAsn't that before Silva popping for roids, Jones popping a second time, Fedor getting KO'd multiple times and GSP winning the MW strap? I think so.

Pro fighters’ opinion > Canadians on Sherdog


Thought some might like a count as opposed to the jumbled mess.

Fedor: 37
Silva: 36
Jones: 29
GSP: 16

 

[tehMoose]

Fedor
GSP
Jones
Silva