Let’s be completely honest, Shogun would’ve...

[Typrune Goatley]

 

[SKITZADACTYL]

shogun has always been pretty tailor made for someone like silva, wild looping shots vs an accurate counter striker.

 

[You no hespect]

Shogun beats non juiced jones

 

[true_fan]

Did you forget that your idol Rua got tapped out by chael sonnen ?

Spider got choked out by little Japanese dude you forgot!

 

[true_fan]

shogun has always been pretty tailor made for someone like silva, wild looping shots vs an accurate counter striker.

Yeah, look what happened to the Machida’s era!

 

[AC1D1K]

shogun would make andy wish he still worked at macdonalds

 

[SKITZADACTYL]

Yeah, look what happened to the Machida’s era!

wow machida, a completely different fighter, lost to shogun.


good job.

 

[MRDOG]

I don't agree ....

Any version of shogun that fought in the UFC gets destroyed by a Prime Anderson Silva.

Today the fight would be a coin toss.

 

[Pancake Sprawl]

I know, but back then People laughed at the idea that Rua had even a slim chance. Then Chris came along and suddenly spider is out of his prime!

agree with this. as soon as Anderson lost, he was out of his prime and "messing around too much". of course, he "messed around" in every fight he ever had pretty much in UFC. they don't realize this, it's not "messing around" it's psychological warfare and it worked every other time before he fought Weidman.

 

[true_fan]

Shogun Griffin- Loss
Shogun Henderson- Loss X2
Shogun Chael- Loss

Silva Griffin- Win
Silve Henderon- Win
Silva Chael- Win X2

These two arent in the same league.
Never have been

Mmamath?????????????????? He was busted twice juicing and lost to 2 little Japanese guys when Shogun was killing guys there

 

[true_fan]

wow machida, a completely different fighter, lost to shogun.


good job.

Yeah but they sparr together and machida was the better fighter

 

[true_fan]

agree with this. as soon as Anderson lost, he was out of his prime and "messing around too much". of course, he "messed around" in every fight he ever had pretty much in UFC. they don't realize this, it's not "messing around" it's psychological warfare and it worked every other time before he fought Weidman.

It’s pathetic when you hear those kind of things! He won, king of the hill, but he lost because that last fight he won was the last strand of his prime. Then he wins again, he is back

 

[Paynebringer]

Sure why not it's Sunday I'll roll with it...

 

[MrFeeny]

Shogun got choked out within second against Chael

I cant imagine what Silva would do to him

uh, your realize silva got choked out and subbed against two guys that make chael seem like a goat candidate right?

 

[SKITZADACTYL]

Yeah but they sparr together and machida was the better fighter

lol ok

 

[ermac88]

uh, your realize silva got choked out and subbed against two guys that make chael seem like a goat candidate right?

Common opponent plus
Add Griffin
And Henderson

Shoguns taken far too many losses to be remotely compared to Silva

 

[BlancoDiablo828]

No, but

You forgot Shogun can take him down and pound him out too! Plus, Silva said Dragon got the best of him sparring

If Chael can sub Shogun so can Andy.

 

[true_fan]

If Chael can sub Shogun so can Andy.

MMAMATH doesn’t work! Shogun will take Silva’s best and finish him like he did Machida because his style is perfect to kill the spider, granite chin, leg kicks, brawler with dynamite in both legs and fists, great bjj

 

[Jon Stark]

2005 Shogun beats 2005 Anderson. I agree.

 

[treestump]

Cmon bro I think you've forgotten who prime Shogun was.

This was prime Shogun, Anderson never had this level of brutality could you imagine if they'd met in Pride?

Before all his knee surgeries he was one of the most dynamic strikers in MMA.

Beat Prime Rampage, Machida, Arona, Overeem x 2, Lil Nog, Chuck, Arona.

Who's the best striker Anderson beat? Vitor before TRT? Franklin? Cote?

That Shogun would have beat the shit out Jones