Cotto or Shane, who do you rate higher AT?

[wilddeuces]

Shane got gifted a couple wins that would swing people's opinions about him. That being said, I think if you go and call one of them overrated, you might as well call the other one overrated too (not that I think they necessarily are, both are solid, both have turned in good performances on many occasions).

 

[DannyNL]

I think Shane was better p4p.

LW Shane was fucking scary.