Yourr #1 fighter for the glamour weight classes?

[XThe GreatestX]

I do my p4p lists by resume so this is mine

Hw: Ali

Lhw: Archie Moore

MW: Robinson

WW: Robinson ( maybe srl or floyd?)

Lw: One of the tougher picks. Im gonna go Duran but there are a lot of guys who did well at LW

FW: another tough one. Honestly Pep doesn’t have a great resume despite having a lot of wins. I guess Armstrong, Arguello and Saddler are the three. I think I’ll go Saddler

BW: by resume its Jofre or Herman

Fly: Wilde

 

[Kowboy On Sherdog]

Not going to lie... P4P is an opinion, but when it comes from a hardcore fan much more respected... When it comes to Boxing it is legit since you have legends and legends to argue and compare records and opponents... Not like with MMA where if Ferguson wins vs Cowboy and people call him GOAT and never tasted the actual belt...

Interested to see what people have...

 

[FlowchartRog]

What do you mean by P4P by weight class? This contradicts the whole concept of P4P - which is the best fighters across any divisions, ie a who beats who list, if they were all the same size.

Do you mean simply the GOAT of each weight class?

 

[XThe GreatestX]

What do you mean by P4P by weight class? This contradicts the whole concept of P4P - which is the best fighters across any divisions, ie a who beats who list, if they were all the same size.

Do you mean simply the GOAT of each weight class?

Yes will change title lol

Edit: and good catch!

 

[cottagecheesefan]

Fw: pac

Lw: floyd

Ww: srl

Mw: rjj

Lhw: rjj

Cw: holyfield

Hw: Lennox

 

[FlowchartRog]

Yes will change title lol

Edit: and good catch!

 

[Mr.Maelstrom]

Fw: pac

Lw: floyd

Ww: srl

Mw: rjj

Lhw: rjj

Cw: holyfield

Hw: Lennox

That's as sound a list as any. +1