Wrestler vs Wrestler Game

Scott Steiner and it's not even close. Scott Steiner, for a period of 3-4 years, had it all especially in what you would want in a star. The pacing, ringwork, aerial and power moves, the look, the body and the only thing missing during that period was proven mic work.

Shane Douglas vs Tommy Dreamer
 
Shane Douglas - a brilliant heel promo and good face worker, Tommy probably wasn't quite as versatile.

William Regal vs Davey Boy Smith
 
Regal

Fuck the bulldogs for the way they used to mistreat animals

King Maxel Hardy or Vanguard 1
 
Vanguard 1

It motorboated ODB

Ricky steamboat vs dean malenko
 
Last edited:
Steamboat. I think of him having the greater legacy, he's involved in the bigger matches and events.

Lou Thesz or Bruno Sammartino
 
Sammartino although, that is a very close call. Sammartino I think is just a bit more iconic than Thesz.

Mankind vs Cactus Jack
 
As a territories guy I wanted to pick Cactus Jack but Mankind has the Jim Ross attack promo and the Hell In A Cell while Cactus has the damn horse stall bit with Abdullah
Gotta be Mankind

Dusty Rhodes as Stardust in Florida in the 70's or as the Common Man in WWF in the 90's
 
70's Dusty all day. His E run was only like 3 years long.


Hacksaw Jim Duggan or The Junkyard Dog.
 
Hmm, though on. As a kid, I was more partial to Jim Duggan. I think JYD had the better in ring matches but Jim Duggan was fun to watch. This is basically a wash to me but I'll give it to Mr. 2x4 since he had a longer run in the big promotions.

Doink or Santino
 
GSPSAKU said:
Hmm, though on. As a kid, I was more partial to Jim Duggan. I think JYD had the better in ring matches but Jim Duggan was fun to watch. This is basically a wash to me but I'll give it to Mr. 2x4 since he had a longer run in the big promotions.

Doink or Santino
Click to expand...


Doink by a country mile. Doink for being a memorable heel and entertaining character for his first few years in the WWF.

Texas Tornado Kerry Von Erich vs Diamond Dallas Paige
 
DDP because he busted his ass and beat huge odds to get to the top, Kerry had the whole world handed to him and he threw it away

Missy Hyatt or Fallen Angel
 
Pliny Pete said:
DDP because he busted his ass and beat huge odds to get to the top, Kerry had the whole world handed to him and he threw it away

Missy Hyatt or Fallen Angel
Click to expand...

What fallen angel are you talking about? I can only think of the Christopher Daniels "Fallen Angel" gimmick.
 
Edison Carasio said:
I'll have to go with Hyatt since never heard of the other.

The Iron Sheik or Rusev
Click to expand...


The Iron Sheik- dude would load his curled toed boot with that toe tap!!

The Wild Samoans vs. The Moon Dogs
 
SammyPops said:
The Iron Sheik- dude would load his curled toed boot with that toe tap!!

The Wild Samoans vs. The Moon Dogs
Click to expand...

Wild Samoans. When I was a kid I literally thought all the Samoan wrestlers were plucked out of the jungle somewhere. Kayfabe 4 lyfe.

The Bushwhackers (WWF) vs. The Headshrinkers
 
Bushwhackers; 30 years later their gimmick is still momorable to even the most casual of fans.

Next: Golberg or the Ultimate Warrior?
 
gspieler said:
Bushwhackers; 30 years later their gimmick is still momorable to even the most casual of fans.

Next: Golberg or the Ultimate Warrior?
Click to expand...


Warrior- him and Hogan ruled!! So sad when he ended Honky Tonk Man's run.

The Missing Link vs. George 'the Animal' Steel?
 
George Steele, far more cultural impact due to being on a far bigger stage.

The Shockmaster vs The Gobbledy Gooker
 
Uncle Fred, based strictly on his association with Dusty

The Freebirds or the Von Erichs
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,237,897
Messages
55,524,647
Members
174,809
Latest member
BackagainBert

Share this page

Back
Top