No love for sweet pea vs haugen /nelson/jlr?
Hell his draw against jcc was quality boxing?
He's probably my favorite boxer of all-time and always fun to compare and contrast with Duran (also in my top five); had a really strong albeit understated level of opposition too.
03/88: Jose Luis Ramirez (100-6) [Top 3 LW; WBC champ]
02/89: Greg Haugen (23-1) [Top 3 LW; IBF champ]
04/89: Louie Lomeli (24-0) [Top 10 LW]
08/89: Jose Luis Ramirez (102-7) [Top 3 LW; vacant WBC]
02/90: Freddie Pendleton (24-16) [Top 5 LW]
05/90: Azumah Nelson (32-1) [SFW Champ; #6 P4P] (@135)
08/90: Juan Nazario (22-2) [Top 3 LW; WBA champ]
02/91: Anthony Jones (26-2) [Top 5 LW]
07/91: Poli Diaz (32-0) [Top 5 LW]
10/91: Jorge Paez (38-3) [Top 3 LW]
07/92: Rafael Pineda (28-1) [Top 2 LWW; IBF champ]
03/93: Buddy McGirt (59-2) [WW Champ; #4 P4P]
09/93: Julio Cesar Chavez (87-0) [LWW Champ; #1 P4P] (@145)
10/94: Buddy McGirt (64-3) [Top 3 WW]
03/95: Julio Cesar Vasquez (53-1) [Top 2 LMW; WBC champ]
04/96: Wilfredo Rivera (23-0 [Top 10 WW]
09/96: Wilfredo Rivera (23-1) [Top 10 WW]
04/97: Oscar De La Hoya (23-0) [LWW Champ; #2 P4P] (@147)
10/97: Andrey Pestreyaev (20-1) [Top 10 WW]
02/99: Felix Trinidad (33-0) [Top 2 WW; #4 P4P; IBF champ]
Nobody on Whitaker's 135 ledger as good as '72 Buchanan or '74 DeJesus aside from Azumah Nelson - a better overall fighter than either - who was challenging for the title as the guy at super featherweight. However, he beat far more of the ordinary top five rated guys of his era, contender types where nothing in particular stands out as far as ability goes. And by about twice as many as Roberto fought in the 1970s. A faded Jose Luis Ramirez is still a good scalp, and the absolutely dominating fashion he did it in also boosts.
If Duran is a Top 5 ATG lightweight most notably for the dominating fashion in which he ruled, then so is Whitaker. Performances such as Haugen, Ramirez II and Nelson were absurdly good. Nazario too I guess considering he one-punch KO'ed him to unify the division. Most of his big legacy work in terms of top wins obviously took place post-135 in beating McGirt (x2), JCC and Vasquez, thoroughly dominating Chavez and McGirt (in the rematch). The De La Hoya and Trinidad fights were fucking ballsy. He went the distance with a broken jaw for six rounds against Tito. Imagine he'd won both of those and not just the Oscar fight.