I would take the time-stopping ability. There's lots of rich guys but there's nobody that can freeze time. I'm sure you could figure out a way to get rich without even committing crimes.
I mean one rich dude might pay you millions if you rescue his daughter from kidnappers.
You could work as a police consultant like Adrian Monk but you'd be able to search anyone's house without a warrant.
Not to mention that freezing time could save your life. What if someone points a gun at you? Freeze time, unload the gun, kick him in the nuts 47 times, then unfreeze time and watch him collapse in agony.. Easy peasy.