Would Weidman considered MW GOAT if he retired after beating Vitor

[heohanwuoc]

3 title defenses, undefeated, never lose a round, dethroned the MW GOAT Anderson Silva.

 

[Deceasedxo]

Nah

 

[JustBleed69]

Lol no.

 

[Ares Black]

No lol.

 

[Juicy Jon]

I've discussed this topic before he could of retired then with wins over Silva x2, Maia, Munhoz, Vitor, Lyoto and Hall. Undefeated UFC and 3 title defences. Similar situation to Khabib.

That being said retiring early don't give you extra goat points, Anderson defended that belt 10 times and didn't lose in UFC until he was 37.

 

[Dave Poodle]

People speculated he could be if he got thru Rockhold, Romero and Jacare. He lost to all of them.

 

[Goatenstein]

I've discussed this topic before he could of retired then with wins over Silva x2, Maia, Munhoz, Vitor, Lyoto and Hall. Undefeated UFC and 3 title defences. Similar situation to Khabib.

That being said retiring early don't give you extra goat points, Anderson defended that belt 10 times and didn't lose in UFC until he was 37.

Lol like a win over Hall means anything in GOAT discussion.

 

[loisestrad]

No, obviously not. But he would be a mythical creature, and he would be held in way higher regards than now, and we would have threads on a weekly basis saying: "Yeah, but Weidman would destroy that dude".

 

[Ozze]

Nope.

 

[Jackonfire]

 

[yekmurat]

One of the biggest hyped guys out there
On the other hand to KO prime Silva was huge as fuck

 

[Elvis.]

Nope

 

[Otto!]

No way.

 

[iwantgsp]

Beating washed, old Brazilians doesn't make someone a GOAT.

 

[Only Here for Attachments]

He’d just be ducking whoever the next big thing was

 

[iwantgsp]

One of the biggest hyped guys out there
On the other hand to KO prime Silva was huge as fuck

Prime? lol

 

[Superior]

No no no.

 

[Rock3091]

No way Play Boi!

 

[XociDe]

He wouldn't have dethroned Anderson as the GOAT but it is very similar to how Khabib ran away while on top after a few defenses. Weidman looked near unbeatable during that time.

 

[pankrat]

No no