Who's top 5 wins are better Stipe or Fedor's?

[Steve-French]

Stipe
1 .Fabrico Werdum
2. JDS
3. Francis Ngannou
4. Alistair Overeem
5. Mark Hunt
HM: Andrei Arlovski

Fedor
1. Nog
2. Cro Cop
3. Andrei Arlovski
4. Tim Slyvia
5. Semmy Schilt
HM: Mark Hunt

 

[Medical Marijuana Man]

Nogueira is the best win and he did it twice

 

[Orochimaru 大蛇丸]

In b4 old people hype Fedor up

 

[3sumrock]

Stipe and the way he beat them is more impressive
I

 

[MikeyB]

If Stipe beat Cain, I'd have pick Stipe. However based on time period I'm going with Fedor.

 

[gono btw]

Stipe
1 .Fabrico Werdum
2. JDS
3. Francis Ngannou
4. Alistair Overeem
5. Mark Hunt
HM: Andrei Arlovski

Fedor
1. Nog
2. Cro Cop
3. Andrei Arlovski
4. Tim Slyvia
5. Semmy Schilt
HM: Mark Hunt

Minotau>
Volk Han
Mirko Cro Cop (finish)
Fabrício Werdum
Ricco Rodriguez
Sergei Kharitonov or Semmy Schilt

HM: Sergei Kharitonov or Semmy Schilt

 

[Medical Marijuana Man]

Stipe and the way he beat them is more impressive
I

Jds is a shell of himself along with Arlovski and Reem. Big names but not in their prime like Nog and CC.

 

[Summoning]

 

[3sumrock]

Jds is a shell of himself along with Arlovski and Reem. Big names but not in their prime like Nog and CC.

Both Reem and arlovski was on 4+ fight winning streak.
And a lot of people think jds was in his prime base on his Rothwell performance

 

[RetiredSlave]

Id put Herring instead of Semmy since Semmy was pretty much purely a striker. Also Herring was completely decimated by Fedor and it made people really notice him for the first time. I have to go with Fedor for the better wins. Prime Nog and prime Crocop sealing that opinion. Stipe beat old reckless Werdum, shell of his former self JDS, one dimensional Ngannou, frequently KOd Reem and an old disillusioned Hunt.

Both are impressive though.

 

[Medical Marijuana Man]

Fedors best wins

Nog 2x
Crocop
Sylvia
Arlovski
Coleman 2x
Randleman
Mir
Schilt
Herring
Arona
Roger's

 

[gono btw]

Both Reem and arlovski was on 4+ fight winning streak.
And a lot of people think jds is in his prime base on his Rothwell performance

Everybody knows JDS lost something after the 2 last Cain fights.

 

[locust rising]

Nogueira is the best win and he did it twice

Werdum>nog

 

[3sumrock]

Everybody knows JDS lost something after the 2 last Cain fights.

Doesn’t change the fact that jds is still amazing
And I love how fedor fans doesn’t mention that Tim Sylvia,Coleman,randleman were out of prime but still nitpicking every stipe wins

 

[RoyJonesJr]

Fedor fought more fighters in their prime

But Stipe has beat more impressive fighters


guys like Werdum, Hunt, and Overeem eally improved since Pride and Stipe starched all of them.

 

[Medical Marijuana Man]

Both Reem and arlovski was on 4+ fight winning streak.
And a lot of people think jds was in his prime base on his Rothwell performance

No one thinks JDS is in his prime after the 2 beat downs Cain gave him. No one.

Reem had a good streak going for this stage in his career but 1 punch and he folds and wilts like he always does.

Arlovski beat Browne. Thats really it. He loss to Schaub and had a stare down with Mir.

Beating Arlovski in 2015 isnt the same as 2009

 

[Medical Marijuana Man]

Doesn’t change the fact that jds is still amazing
And I love how fedor fans doesn’t mention that Tim Sylvia,Coleman,randleman were out of prime but still nitpicking every stipe wins

Randleman in 2004 was out of his prime? Lol he just knocked out Prime Crocop ya goof

Sylvia was top 5 HW along with Arlovski

 

[Medical Marijuana Man]

Werdum>nog

Nog fought clean and arguably has the best wins at HW

 

[gono btw]

Doesn’t change the fact that jds is still amazing
And I love how fedor fans doesn’t mention that Tim Sylvia,Coleman,randleman were out of prime but still nitpicking every stipe wins

Must be coz dudes like u keep sayin that the whole Hammer House was fookin roided out of their minds, which means their "out-of-their-prime" thing becomes quite relative...lmao

 

[3sumrock]

No one thinks JDS is in his prime after the 2 beat downs Cain gave him. No one.

Reem had a good streak going for this stage in his career but 1 punch and he folds and wilts like he always does.

Arlovski beat Browne. Thats really it. He loss to Schaub and had a stare down with Mir.

Beating Arlovski in 2015 isnt the same as 2009

Arlovski was on 6 fight winning streak
Reem was on 4 fight winning streak
Jds was still amazing

Randleman in 2004 was out of his prime? Lol he just knocked out Prime Crocop ya goof

Sylvia was top 5 HW along with Arlovski

Randleman prime years was in his ufc and he was losing left and right in pride
Tim was fat And way out of shape when he fought fedor