Who scored every round for Aldo?

[ExitLUPin]

Live i had it 49-46 with Frankie taking the 1st. On a rewatch i had Aldo stealing the 1st round in the last minute. He landed a big right hand, couple big knees (one to the body and one to the face), body kick and the flying counter left hook. The 3rd was a bit closer mightve been 10-10.

I could see scoring every round for Jose tho.

 

[Goodfella86]

I did. I haven't rewatched it yet, but I had Jose winning all 5. All were close; some were very close. I'll have to see it again.

 

[zerofux]

Aldo seemed to take the third round off and I gave that one to Frankie, the rest to Aldo.

 

[Bokelj]

I gave Frankie one round. And that one could have gone either way

 

[Magx951]

It was a really close fight, im astonished at how bad at judging sherdog is. Aldo COULD win all 5 rounds but it wasn't an easy win by any stretch. I gave it 48-47 frankie.

 

[Angle Shooter]

I had Aldo winning all but the 3rd.

 

[Kryptt]

By a hair every round and highly debatable (obviously).

 

[Drake]

The first round was the round i'm assuming they gave to Frankie & I thought it was very close so, yeah. Four rounds to Aldo.

 

[ExitLUPin]

It was a really close fight, im astonished at how bad at judging sherdog is. Aldo COULD win all 5 rounds but it wasn't an easy win by any stretch. I gave it 48-47 frankie.

It wasnt close at all. Multiple media scored it 50-45 Aldo, two judges had it 49-46 and both disagreed on the round Frankie won.

Jose 50-45 is a far more reasonable scorecard than any Frankie win.

 

[Drunken Bobby]

On initial watch I had round 1 to Edgar and 2-5 to Aldo

 

[Magx951]

It wasnt close at all. Multiple media scored it 50-45 Aldo, two judges had it 49-46 and both disagreed on the round Frankie won.

Jose 50-45 is a far more reasonable scorecard than any Frankie win.

Media scores mean nothing, in case you haven't noticed MMA media is fucking retarded

if you look at the stats (what you should look at for a decision, not "visible" damage) its about as tight as it gets.

 

[chunglii]

I gave Frankie the 3rd for sure. Maybe the 5th? I remember Aldo backed up a lot in that round with way less offense. I'd have to rewatch it. 49-46 Aldo though.

 

[Barteh]

I thought Aldo won the last four rounds, but the first round was close. Could easily be a draw, but rounds are rarely scored 10-10. One thing is clear is that Aldo showed throughout the entire fight that he is the superior fighter.

 

[Jorge Luis Borges]

It was a really close fight, im astonished at how bad at judging sherdog is. Aldo COULD win all 5 rounds but it wasn't an easy win by any stretch. I gave it 48-47 frankie.

No, it wasn't all that close. It's possible Frankie won the third, and if you really stretch, you could give him the first as well.

If you think Frankie won that fight, then the bad judge is you.

 

[tdluxon]

Soun

Live i had it 49-46 with Frankie taking the 1st. On a rewatch i had Aldo stealing the 1st round in the last minute. He landed a big right hand, couple big knees (one to the body and one to the face), body kick and the flying counter left hook. The 3rd was a bit closer mightve been 10-10.

I could see scoring every round for Jose tho.

sounds about right to me. 1st and 3rd were really close, argueable either way. It just seemed like Aldo was always landing a little harder shots

 

[Jorge Luis Borges]

Media scores mean nothing, in case you haven't noticed MMA media is fucking retarded

if you look at the stats (what you should look at for a decision, not "visible" damage) its about as tight as it gets.

Visible damage can be misleading, but so can fight stats. Aldo's shots were clearly better and harder shots, and thus his striking was much more effective than Frankie's.

 

[Hans Gercmiov]

I did. I was a little drunk though so idk. I think most judges are drunk too.

 

[akc814ilv]

I had all 5 for aldo. I think you can make a case for Frankie possibly winning two of those rounds, if you base it on aggression, but ultimately I felt it was a very easy fight to score.

 

[ChangeIsComing]

I had it 48-47 Aldo, Frankie took the 1 and 2 with being more active and landing, Aldo at the end of the 2nd and the rest of the fight coasted.

Was a pretty uneventful fight with neither guy really going for it...just like the first fight.

Aldo loses to Mcgregor again though.

 

[FlowchartKen]

Scoring it live I had it the same as you did, Frankie winning the first, Aldo winning the next 4.