Who is the greatest fighter of all time?

[Heelhook71]

Fedor is the greatest heavy weight. But Jones has to be the most gifted. Anderson always had holes in his game.

 

[tkotom]

settle down nutthugger.

as an aside, how you know fedor was clean in pride?

At least I'd have some nuts to hug, steroid boy.

 

[hot carl]

At least I'd have some nuts to hug, steroid boy.

send pics??

 

[Mixedfights]

Time is still happening.

 

[jumasterflex]

No he shouldnt. Great for his time but he isnt close to being GOAT level.

Thats why this kind of diacussion is horsecrap there are many different eras and fighters will always be getting better then the previous era im sure in five years people will be laughing at the thought of gsp bones and anderson as greats saying oh so and so from right now would have mopped the floor with them theyre not worth bringing up

 

[HARDCORE CHINO]

1. fedor
2. A. silva
3. GSP
4. JBJ

 

[myjohnson9]

settle down nutthugger.

as an aside, how you know fedor was clean in pride?

Fedor was in Olympic sambo, he was prob one of the few fighters of that time that was tested

 

[BOGS DIAM0ND]

The Great Fedor Emelianenko!!!

 

[Money509]

The fedor nuthuggery is strong on sherdog. He ducked the UFC his whole career that alone means he isnt the GOAT. Also ducked reem in strikeforce.

 

[105]

I voted GSP as he took on all comers in the weightclass, was clean, and left the division as champ... But you can make solid arguments for anyone on that list, really...


AND NO CONOR!?!?!? I'm ashamed.

 

[bettergenes]

The fedor nuthuggery is strong on sherdog. He ducked the UFC his whole career that alone means he isnt the GOAT. Also ducked reem in strikeforce.

Tell me who exactly he ducked in the UFC HW division. Also, tell me in which way UFC HW division was better when Pride was alive.
I'm waiting.

Don't ever mention Overeem who had like 50:1 T/E ratio in UFC and got suspended.

 

[DuppyMekka]

Sakuraba imho...

 

[alexxx]

the sky is blue and grass is green,and fedor wins the GOAT poll

 

[Rum]

It's between Aldo, GSP and Fedor.

It's GSP.

 

[Chael Sonnen]

 

[Bacco]

The fedor nuthuggery is strong on sherdog. He ducked the UFC his whole career that alone means he isnt the GOAT. Also ducked reem in strikeforce.

His whole career?

LOL

In all his prime years UFC was'nt a scary place for him

In his later decline years Strikeforce had an equally if not more scary HW division than UFC

 

[Kinger85]

just as long as Fedor, Anderson, GSP, and Jones are your top 4, in some order, then your list is fine.

 

[Ivanhoe]

Fedor >= GSP >>>>>>>>>> the rest

 

[machidafan99]

DJ will never win this because we are pricks

 

[chinarice]

I voted GSP because he is my favourite fighter out of the options available.

That's how I roll.