- Joined
- Jul 21, 2015
- Messages
- 15,966
- Reaction score
- 25,430
I disagree about Yan having lots of trouble with guys in round 1, it's kind of revisionist history - until Sterling he'd won the first round against every single UFC opponent: Ishihara, Jin Too Son, Silva de Andrade, Dodson, Rivera, Faber, Aldo. That's 8 first-rounds in a row he wins to start his UFC career and somehow he "always gives away the first round" according to some.
It's definitely pretty crazy/strange that he loses the first round to Sterling both times with Sterling not getting a takedown either time. Yan also lost the first-round to Corey, so I guess there became some sort of narrative around that time painting him as a slow-starter, when he really isn't in 3-round fights - against Aldo in his first 5-rounder is when we saw him fight a slower pace and almost lose the first until he landed that body shot. He was also losing the first against Rivera before he dropped him with like 10 seconds left in the round, but because of the Jellyfish incident (had to travel 20 hours and cut weight after getting badly stung) prior I think it's fair to give him a pass in that one. It's fair to say he starts slow and tends to give away the first in 5-round fights because he feels with his style/approach he'll come on strong late in the fight - which he is 100% right about, he always does. It's just a razor's edge approach against top-level fighters if you don't make those adjustments by the middle of the second.
I think you just highly overrate Gutierrez and his improvements - the fight against Durden was 2 years ago when he was 29 and already had 20+ pro fights, he'd been fighting pro for 7-8 years and basically in his prime. You were saying that realistically you could see Gutierrez catching Yan and finishing him, when again he's never been finished/rarely is hurt (has insane chin) and Gutierrez has an over-inflated KO ratio in 9 fights since it's only 3 with 1 leg kick TKO and the other being Edgar's retirement fight. He isn't a hitter and yet somehow he is going to KO a notoriously tough guy to hurt/finish?
Yan also is incredibly fast comparatively and he'd have more diverse attacks, better defensive layers, better pressure, and just overall a more systematic approach. It would likely look a lot like Nathaniel Wood vs. Charles Jourdain just even more dominant for the slightly smaller but faster/smarter/more diverse fighter.
The "giving away the first round" thing does get overblow, I'll admit. It's more that he always gets outlanded in those rounds, even if he does actually win them. I think Guti is closer to the level of Cory and Aljo than some of the other, lesser guys Yan's faced, and would have a higher chance of taking that first round. Again, not because he's way better, but just because of the way Yan likes to take his time in r1.
I had no idea about the jelly fish incident with Yan. That's wild.
Maybe Yan would still win and I am overrating Guti a bit, but I don't think it'd be anything like Woods/Jourdain. Guti doesn't fight like either guy, even if Yan does fight similar to Woods. Guti likes his space while Jourdain doesn't really care. Then again, Yan's forward pressure is stronger than Woods', and he might be able to force it on Guti anyway, in which case Guti would be getting wrecked lol.