When Frankie becomes Featherweight Champ

[Frankie Baby!]

Should he drop to Bantamweight, and if he wins the belt there, is he GOAT?

If not GOAT, surely top 3 GOATs.

His resume would be amazing
BJ Penn X3
Gray Maynard(when he was good)
Cub Swanson
Urijah Faber
Chad Mendes
Jeremy Stephens
Brian Ortega
Max Holloway
TJ Dillashaw

 

[tenniswhiz]

Only a HW or LHW can be the GOAT

 

[Frankie Baby!]

Only a HW or LHW can be the GOAT

Bob Sapp

 

[Evangelion]

Hes not beating Max or Dillashaw. Those are fucking massive ifs.

 

[3sumrock]

He would get destroy by top 3 bw(Cruz,Tj and Cody)

 

[Frankie Baby!]

He would get destroy by top 3 bw(Cruz,Tj and Cody)

Dom would be hard, but not impossible. He'd wrestle fuck TJ, and Cody.

 

[Shaddows]

Should he drop to Bantamweight, and if he wins the belt there, is he GOAT?

If not GOAT, surely top 3 GOATs.

His resume would be amazing
BJ Penn X3
Gray Maynard(when he was good)
Cub Swanson
Urijah Faber
Chad Mendes
Jeremy Stephens
Brian Ortega
Max Holloway
TJ Dillashaw

Frankie is one of my favorite fighters.
But let us not start with GOAT talks just yet.

yes, he beat BJ P, but IMO it was not prime BJ... and his third fight...whatever it was, should not be counted as any accomplishment by anyone...

And I would not want him to move down to BW... but if he could do it, it would be an amazing feat (champion is 3 divisions) and will kill all Conor's schtick.

 

[Frankie Baby!]

Hes not beating Max or Dillashaw. Those are fucking massive ifs.

You say that now, but when he's the 145 Champ, you'll be on the Frankie train too.

 

[PAPERCLIP30]

He’s already P4P goat if ya ask me.

If he became a 3 division champ there would be no denying it. It’s a tough task though.

 

[Frankie Baby!]

Frankie is one of my favorite fighters.
But let us not start with GOAT talks just yet.

yes, he beat BJ P, but IMO it was not prime BJ... and his third fight...whatever it was, should not be counted as any accomplishment by anyone...

And I would not want him to move down to BW... but if he could do it, it would be an amazing feat (champion is 3 divisions) and will kill all Conor's schtick.

Well when he beats Max, and moves down the GOAT talk will be immenet.

 

[3sumrock]

Dom would be hard, but not impossible. He'd wrestle fuck TJ, and Cody.

Wrestle Tj and Cody? Both of them got great tdd as shown when they fought Cruz

 

[Frankie Baby!]

He’s already P4P goat if ya ask me.

If he became a 3 division champ there would be no denying it. It’s a tough task though.

Frankie's the man to do it.

 

[Kung Fu bb]

I´m a huge Edgar fan and he´s my in top 5 favourite fighters of all time.

Edgar will obviously be part of a small group of great fighters, but Fedor is the only GOAT. And that´s it. Finish. Period. There shouldn´t be any doubts about this anymore. He defied the laws of the universe when he went on a decade undefeated as HW.

 

[Frankie Baby!]

Wrestle Tj and Cody? Both of them got great tdd as shown when they fought Cruz

They all have great TDD until Frankie gets ahold of em.

 

[Frankie Baby!]

I´m a huge Edgar fan and he´s my in top 5 favourite fighters of all time.

But Fedor is the only GOAT. And that´s it. Finish. Period. There shouldn´t be any doubts about this anymore. He defied the laws of the universe when he went on a decade undefeated as HW.

Aldo went 10 years undefeated, Beat Faber, Cub, Hominick, Florian, Pre-USADA Mendes X2, Frankie, Korean Zombie, Lamas. Aldo is better than Fedor.

 

[Yung Dilla]

Frankie is one of my favorite fighters.
But let us not start with GOAT talks just yet.

yes, he beat BJ P, but IMO it was not prime BJ... and his third fight...whatever it was, should not be counted as any accomplishment by anyone...

And I would not want him to move down to BW... but if he could do it, it would be an amazing feat (champion is 3 divisions) and will kill all Conor's schtick.

Bj was most definitely in his phone 2/3 of those fights he was a dominant let champ. Majority say he won the first fight (I agree bj won that first fight) but Frankie is so good the second fight he inproved so much it was a shut out. Bj was a animal then.

 

[wolfss]

He would get destroy by top 3 bw(Cruz,Tj and Cody)

I’d give TJ the edge vs Frankie, and would not be surprised if he beat cody.

I’m sure!!!!!! He would smash marshmallow fisted Dominic cruz!!!

 

[PeterTheGreat]

Frankie is still my LW Goat. Prime Decisionson Henderson got to him twice in fights he is severely undersized in and still has strong argument of winning both . I thought if he had beat Aldo once he has strong talks in the goat convo

 

[ScarfaceJr]

doubt it
homie jy old to try to cut another 10 lbs to go fight dudes younger and quicker.

 

[fortheo]

Hes not beating Max or Dillashaw. Those are fucking massive ifs.

Dillashank is an easier fight than max. Frankie doesn't lose to guys his size or smaller.


TS, Frankie's one of my favorites, but let's get through Ortega first. Also, Edgar's wins over Sherk and Griffin are underrated.