Pre-Fight consensus was that Anderson was going to eat him... which was never going to happen because Nick is too durable, and too aware of range.
Then post-fight consensus was that Anderson looked like shit, and Nick showed no desire to scrap and was entirely ineffectual... which is entirely untrue as well. Anderson looked good, actually. He threw a number of spectacular fight ending sorts of maneuvers out there and just never landed one because Nick was never out of position. For his part, Nick did a great job of not only avoiding the error of over extending that almost everyone makes against Anderson, but he also did a great job of landing hard shots in the clinch, and finding success with a repeated body/head combo.
It was not a particularly close fight. But both guys performed well. What really had everyone's panties in a bunch was that they wanted to see Anderson flat line Nick, they were certain that's what they would see, and when they didn't, they wanted to complain about a bunch of bullshit instead of giving some credit where it was due.