welterweight has gotten worse

Mal Intentions

Mal Intentions

Brown Belt
@Brown
Joined
Aug 1, 2010
Messages
3,113
Reaction score
2,246
the top 10 welterweights from 10 years ago would all give the top 10 from today a good run. do people really think gsp, kos, fitch, hughes, shields, and hendricks, diaz, etc... wouldnt at least be extremely competitive with the likes of Usman and Colby? i dont see colby beating anyone from my list if they fought in their prime.
 
I don't know what you think Fitch, Shields or Hughes would do to Colby, none of them are taking him down and he's a lot better than them on the feet.
 
Hellowhosthat said:
I don't know what you think Fitch, Shields or Hughes would do to Colby, none of them are taking him down and he's a lot better than them on the feet.
Click to expand...
they all would have a solid chance at taking him down. much bigger and just as credentialed. shields would easily beat colby. and by easily i mean really easily
 
They were all allowed to juice freely, but other than that the skill ceiling has gotten much higher. Most of the guys were very 1 dimensional
 
Mal Intentions said:
they all would have a solid chance at taking him down. much bigger and just as credentialed. shields would easily beat colby. and by easily i mean really easily
Click to expand...

Huh? Now that you mention it, I think Shields would beat Colby! I can’t see Fitch or Hughes beating him though. I think Colby destroys both of them.
 
Frank Edgar said:
They were all allowed to juice freely, but other than that the skill ceiling has gotten much higher. Most of the guys were very 1 dimensional
Click to expand...
thats total bullshit and there is no proof of any of that. if thats all u have to say then just be quiet
 
Mal Intentions said:
u obviously have no idea who shields is. former MW champ who man handled Dan Henderson. he would treat colby like his little brother
Click to expand...

He beat a gassed Hendo who nearly had him out of there in the first. I'm a big fan of Jake but a guy with endless cardio like Colby who's hard to get down is a bad matchup for him.
 
killakillakilla said:
Huh? Now that you mention it, I think Shields would beat Colby! I can’t see Fitch or Hughes beating him though. I think Colby destroys both of them.
Click to expand...
hughes is literally twice as strong as colby, bigger and a better wrestler.
 
Mal Intentions said:
hughes is literally twice as strong as colby, bigger and a better wrestler.
Click to expand...

I don’t know if Hughes is a better mma wrestler. Colbys defensive wrestling is pretty solid and I think Colby would have the speed advantage. Colby wins by tko
 
Mal Intentions said:
thats total bullshit and there is no proof of any of that. if thats all u have to say then just be quiet
Click to expand...

There is no proof of what you're claiming either lol. You're just speculating about what a past era MIGHT do and being super defensive about it on a fucking forum, you dweeb
 
Hellowhosthat said:
He beat a gassed Hendo who nearly had him out of there in the first. I'm a big fan of Jake but a guy with endless cardio like Colby who's hard to get down is a bad matchup for him.
Click to expand...
u mean he gassed out hendo with his grappling after surviving one of the hardest hitters in the sports history's signature punch? okay
 
Frank Edgar said:
There is no proof of what you're claiming either lol. You're just speculating about what a past era MIGHT do and being super defensive about it on a fucking forum, you dweeb
Click to expand...
ya based on their body of work and accomplishments, not just saying oh theyre on steroids like a total retard
 
Anyway this is how I see the fights.

GSP - Beats Usman and Colby. Tough fight with Usman but I think he's faster and more dynamic.

Koscheck - Punchers chance against Colby because he hits hard, probably loses on volume. Usman breaks his orbital with the jab again.

Fitch - No chance against either. If he can't impose his wrestling on you he's fucked. He struggled with decent wrestlers like Mike Pierce, never mind the likes of Usman and Colby.

Hughes - Too small by modern standards, Usman would dwarf him. Can't see him taking either of them down and doesn't really have anything for them on the feet. If he can somehow get them down he's a better sub grappler than either of them, but I can't see them ending up there.

Shields - See Hughes apart from the size thing.

Hendricks - Pre IV ban Hendricks has a decent chance against either of them, I don' think they can take him down and that power is always a problem.

Diaz - Gets frustratingly 50-45ed by either of them imo.
 
Mal Intentions said:
hughes is literally twice as strong as colby, bigger and a better wrestler.
Click to expand...

You've been an MMA fan over ten years and this is how simplistic your understanding of the sport is?

By this logic all it would ever take to win is big muscles and a strong wrestling base. Striking, footwork, and defensive wrestling would never play a factor in a fight

Hughes's wrestling worked back when the sport was still evolving into what it is now and a guy could be that 1 dimensional and still impose his will on opponents
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,280,626
Messages
58,306,716
Members
176,000
Latest member
Furigo94

Share this page

Back
Top