Weakest resume for goat??

[mister piscadinha]

I’d say Usman for all the ppl on here who actually rate him that high. I don’t personally think he’s a GOAT at all.

people comparing his resume to georges's was ridiculous

dude had 4 title defenses against colby and masvidal

 

[Dana's Moonface]

Wow this is a new thread, how original

 

[Strijfy]

Op is still salty that his boy got whipped.

 

[World eater]

Weekly “Khabib’s resume is too weak for him to be considered goat” thread.

 

[MartinGibson86]

Bj is the goat lw imo.

Mind boggling that anyone would rate BJ ahead of Frankie.

 

[JKS]

You got a handful....Jones, GSP, Anderson, Fedor. It's certainly not Jones, so one of the other 3.

 

[chitoortiz]

He is
3 title defenses
13-0 in the UFC LW division
Also the other guys who had 3 title defenses (Frankie, Benson, BJ Penn) are miles behind in terms of dominance


The guy is not the GOAT but it's laughable to be here pretending he isn't the greatest lightweight to ever step foot in that octagon and a clear top 10 all time fighter and talent.

BJ didn't dominate?

He had the entire LW division scared. Look at his title defenses. Pure domination and very bloody.

Stevenson - left in a pool of his own blood.
Sherk - highlight reel flying knee finish
Florian - domination, finishing him with his own move.
Sanchez - 5 round annihilation. people forget how good Diego was at this point in his career.

 

[MartinGibson86]

people comparing his resume to georges's was ridiculous

dude had 4 title defenses against colby and masvidal

Colby's better than all of GSPs wins and Mas is better than Diaz, Hardy, Alves, or Serra. He also defended against Burns and beat Maia and RDA before the TS

 

[mister piscadinha]

Colby's better than all of GSPs wins and Mas is better than Diaz, Hardy, Alves, or Serra. He also defended against Burns and beat Maia and RDA before the TS

you know nothing about mma

 

[DS7]

BJ didn't dominate?

He had the entire LW division scared. Look at his title defenses. Pure domination and very bloody.

Stevenson - left in a pool of his own blood.
Sherk - highlight reel flying knee finish
Florian - domination, finishing him with his own move.
Sanchez - 5 round annihilation. people forget how good Diego was at this point in his career.

BJ Penn did not dominate like Khabib though and didn't go 13-0 at LW. Khabib's resume is also better. Like i said the body of work of Khabib at LW makes him the undisputed best LW of all time.

 

[Bowel-forged Stool]

A lot of people haven’t been fans for very long, but Aldo is well over Khabib in GOAT conversation. No self respecting Fedor fan can deny this. He ran the division for a decade

 

[MartinGibson86]

you know nothing about mma

I know GSP quit ar 32 right ahead of usada

 

[nonoob]

GOAT used to mean something. Much too vague, using categories would simplify the term.

 

[chitoortiz]

BJ Penn did not dominate like Khabib though and didn't go 13-0 at LW. Khabib's resume is also better. Like i said the body of work of Khabib at LW makes him the undisputed best LW of all time.

That wasn't what I was responding too.

 

[Skarsgard]

Who do you think he would have lost to stylistically?

 

[AfroBanana]

He is
3 title defenses
13-0 in the UFC LW division
Also the other guys who had 3 title defenses (Frankie, Benson, BJ Penn) are miles behind in terms of dominance


The guy is not the GOAT but it's laughable to be here pretending he isn't the greatest lightweight to ever step foot in that octagon and a clear top 10 all time fighter and talent.

11-0 LW he missed weight a few times and had 2 CW fights. People often give him 2 freebies in his division. Like giving Khamzat a WW win in his last fight.

 

[Unfinished Sentenc]

Bj penn is a losing machine even in his prime

 

[ultra321]

compared to whom? cheating ass Jones or Silvia? His later fights were so bad they besmirched his previous accomplishments BJ Penn? "I was a God" until the first spot of trouble, Ronda?

 

[SaigeVanZant]

Fedor

 

[PhilMcCavity]

Look buds. Prime BJ would have killed the most prime version of khabib.

that goes without a doubt.

Lol bj was never that good. Bj fans are a strange breed. I remember all you guys squirting all over the place when he beat caol uno. After the fight Dana was quoted as saying “who gives a shit you fuckin goofs”